Phyllis Logan
Phyllis Logan (born 11 January 1956) is a Scottish actress, widely known for her roles as Lady Jane Felsham in Lovejoy (1986–1993) and Mrs Hughes in Downton Abbey (2010–2015). She won the BAFTA Award for Most Promising Newcomer for the 1983 film Another Time, Another Place and was nominated for BAFTA Award for Best Actress in a Leading Role for the same film. Her other film appearances include Secrets & Lies (1996), Shooting Fish (1997), Downton Abbey (2019) and Misbehaviour (2020).
Phyllis Logan

Mingle MediaTV · Phyllis Logan - DSC_0239 · CC BY-SA 2.0
- Name
- Phyllis Logan
- Born
- 11 January 1956
- Birthplace
- Paisley, Renfrewshire, Scotland
- Education
- Royal Scottish Academy of Music and Drama (1977)
- Occupation
- Actress
- Nationality
- United Kingdom
- Honours
- Screen Actors Guild Award for Outstanding Performance by an Ensemble in a Drama Series · BAFTA Award for Most Promising Newcomer to Leading Film Roles
- Languages
- English
VALÉORINE Encyclopedia
VALÉORINE documentary reading
Documentary summary
Phyllis Logan (born 11 January 1956) is a Scottish actress, widely known for her roles as Lady Jane Felsham in Lovejoy (1986–1993) and Mrs Hughes in Downton Abbey (2010–2015). She won the BAFTA Award for Most Promising Newcomer for the 1983 film Another Time, Another Place and was nominated for BAFTA Award for Best Actress in a Leading Role for the same film. Her other film appearances include Secrets & Lies (1996), Shooting Fish (1997), Downton Abbey (2019) and Misbehaviour (2020).
Admitted source layer · organised and presented by VALÉORINE
Note VALÉORINE
No house-authored Note is published until its assertions and sources pass the VALÉORINE evidence contract. The documentary article remains available in full while that enrichment is being consolidated.
Documentary enrichment in progress · no unsupported statement published
Reference Check
Propose documentary evidence for Phyllis Logan. A contribution is never written directly as fact: identity, source, rights and evidence gates still decide.
Sign in to contribute
Documentary evidence
Evidence Panel
not yet certified
- Identity
- resolved
- Independent source families
- 0
- Admitted assertions
- 0
- Open conflicts
- 0
Authority files
wikidata · Q117995 · wikipedia · Phyllis Logan
In this article
Biography
Biography
Phyllis Logan studied at Royal Conservatoire of Scotland. The recorded working language is English. Distinctions recorded are Screen Actors Guild Award for Outstanding Performance by an Ensemble in a Drama Series and BAFTA Award for Most Promising Newcomer to Leading Film Roles.

The Television Academy Hosts An Afternoon of Tea, Scones and Chatting with Downton Abbey Cast and Creators at Paramount Studios.
Mingle MediaTV · Phyllis Logan - DSC_0239
Key facts
Key facts
• Name — Phyllis Logan • Born — 11 January 1956 • Birthplace — Paisley, Renfrewshire, Scotland • Education — Royal Scottish Academy of Music and Drama (1977) • Occupation — Actress • Years Active — 1977–present • Children — 1
Early life and education
Early life and education
Logan was born in Paisley, Renfrewshire, and grew up nearby Johnstone. Her father, David, was a Rolls-Royce engineer and a trade-union leader and became the secretary of his local branch of the AUEW (Amalgamated Union of Engineering Workers). Logan is the youngest in her family and has a brother and a sister. Her father died at the age of 59 while she was at drama school. Logan was educated at Johnstone High School. She studied at the Royal Scottish Academy of Music and Drama in Glasgow and graduated with the James Bridie gold medal in 1977.
Career
Career
After graduation Logan joined the Dundee Repertory Theatre. She left in 1979 to work on stage in Edinburgh. She also worked regularly on Scottish television. On the BBC Scotland production The White Bird Passes, she first met writer-director Michael Radford. For his first feature film, Another Time, Another Place (1983), he cast Logan in the leading role of Janie, for which she won a Gold Award for Best Actress at the Taormina Film Festival and the Evening Standard Award for Best Actress in 1983 and the BAFTA Award for Most Promising Newcomer to Leading Film Roles in 1984. She was also nominated for the BAFTA Award for Best Actress in a Leading Role. Before her success in Downton Abbey, in which she played the housekeeper Mrs Hughes, Logan was widely known for the role of Lady Jane Felsham, co-starring with Ian McShane, for eight years in nearly fifty episodes of Lovejoy, a comedy-drama for television. Her character in Downton Abbey, Mrs Hughes, was voted the best Downton Abbey character of all time in a poll conducted by RadioTimes.com (the official website of Radio Times). She also starred in the 1996 Mike Leigh film Secrets & Lies alongside Timothy Spall and Brenda Blethyn. Logan provided the broadcast voice of Ingsoc in a film version of Nineteen Eighty-Four (1984) and the Loch Ness Monster (Nessie) in the animated film Freddie as F.R.O.7 (1992). She was in the radio series Coming Alive and Baggage. She played Inspector Frost's love interest and eventual wife in If Dogs Run Free, the last story in the A Touch of Frost series. Logan played Maggie Smart in The Good Karma Hospital (7 episodes, 2017–2018) on the ITV drama series which was later made available on Acorn TV. She also starred in a main role as Linda Hutchinson in the ITV drama series Girlfriends which was created and directed by Kay Mellor, alongside Miranda Richardson and Zoë Wanamaker. She played Andinio in "The Battle of Ranskoor Av Kolos", the tenth episode in the eleventh series of Doctor Who. She starred as Maggie Lynch in the second series of the television series Guilt, which was shown on both BBC Two and BBC Scotland in 2021. At the British Academy Scotland Awards 2022, Logan won the award for Best Actress – Television for the role. She also starred in the third and final series which was released in April 2023, premiering on BBC Scotland on 25 April 2023. In 2024, she played Grace Bain in series 8 of Shetland. In 2025, she played the leading role Cora Felton aka The Puzzle Lady in the first season of Murder Most Puzzling, a television mini-series adaptation of the best-selling murder mystery books by American author Parnell Hall. Logan described the series, written by Dominique Moloney, as "a bit like Murder She Wrote meets Miss Marple on steroids". Logan’s real-life husband, Kevin McNally, plays her character’s love-interest.
Personal life
Personal life
Logan met her now-husband, actor Kevin McNally, in the 1994 mini-series Love and Reason. They married in 2011 and have one son. They live in Chiswick. She supports several charities that promote the welfare of dementia patients, and she is also a supporter of SSPCA.
Television
Television
• Year — Title — Role — Notes • 1980 — Shoestring — Linda — Episode: "Mocking Bird" • The — Janie (age 16) — TV film • 1981 — Beginnings — Nell — TV film • Play for Today — Nancy Park — Episode: "The Good Time Girls" • 1982 — Scotch and Wry — Various — Episode: "Hogmanay 1982" • 1985 — Time and the Conways — Kay Conway — TV film • Off Peak — Janet — TV film • 1986 — Screen Two — Anne — Episode: "The McGuffin" • 1986–1994 — Lovejoy — Lady Jane Felsham — Main role (series 1–5), guest (season 6) • 1987 — First Sight — Kathy — Episode: "Extras" • Bust — Sheila Walsh — TV series • When Reason Sleeps: Out of Time — Helen Wilmot — TV film • 1988 — Hannay — Alison Ross — Episode: "Act of Riot" • 1989 — Screen Two — Alison — Episode: "Sitting Targets" • Lee — Episode: "Defrosting the Fridge" • And a Nightingale Sang — Helen Stott — TV film • Goldeneye — Ann Fleming — TV film • 1991 — Screen One — Dora — Episode: "Happy Feet" • Play on One — Andrea — Episode: "And the Cow Jumped Over the Moon" • Dr Ruth Kovacs — Episode: "Effie's Burning" • 1993 — Love and Reason — Lou Larson — TV miniseries • Silent Cries — Nancy Muir — TV film • 1995 — Kavanagh QC — Samantha Fisher — Episode: "A Family Affair" • The — Mrs. Wilde — TV film • Chiller — Anna Spalinsky — Episode: "Here Comes the Mirror Man" • 1996 — Pie in the Sky — Det. Supt. Chalmers — Episode: "Coddled Eggs" • Inspector Morse — Julia Stevens — Episode: "The Daughters of Cain" • 1997 — Scene — Anna — Episode: "Skinny Marink" • An — Elizabeth Leaming — Episode: "Sacrifice" • 1998 — The Game — Betty McCallum — TV film • Invasion: Earth — Helen Knox — TV miniseries • 1999 — Holby City — Muriel McKendrick — Main role (series 1) • Midsomer Murders — Kate Merrill — Episode: "Strangler's Wood" • Rab C Nesbitt — Jenny Welthorpe — Episode: "Commons" • All the King's Men — Mary Beck — TV film • Heartbeat — Julia Kendall — Episode: "Stag at Bay" • 2000 — Randall and Hopkirk (Deceased) — Harriet Banks-Smith — Episode: "The Best Years of Your Death" • Hope and Glory — Annie Gilbert — Main role (series 3) • 2001 — NCS: Manhunt — Anne Warwick — TV film • 2002 — Dickens — Georgina Hogarth — Episode: "Terror to the End" • Fields of Gold — Rachel Greenlaw — TV film • The Real Jane Austen — Mrs. Austen — TV film • 2003 — The — Miriam Whitelaw — Episode: "Playing for the Ashes" • Alibi — Linda Brentwood — TV film • Agatha Christie's Poirot — Nurse Hopkins — Episode: "Sad Cypress" • 2004 — Dalziel and Pascoe — Jenny Ettrick — Episode: "A Game of Soldiers" • Murder in Suburbia — Wendy — Episode: "Noisy Neighbours" • Silent Witness — Helen Wharton — Episodes: "Death by Water: Parts 1 & 2" • 2005 — Beneath the Skin — DCI Grace Shilling — TV film • 2005, 2006 — Spooks — Diana Jewell — Episodes: "4.8", "5.10" • 2006 — Missing — Karen Foster — TV film • Sea of Souls — Elaine — Episode: "Sleeper" • Heartbeat — Diane Bell — Episode: "Get Back" • 2007 — Richard is My Boyfriend — Laura — TV film • Trial & Retribution — Anna Wildsmith — Episodes: "Curriculum Vitae: Parts 1 & 2" • 2008 — Honest — Jenny — Episode: "1.4" • Taggart — Kathy Moffat — Episode: "Trust" • New Tricks — Dr. Mathieson — Episode: "Mad Dogs" • The — George Fawcett — Episode: "Pastures New" • 2010 — Maid in Britain — TV movie documentary • Silent Witness — Jennifer Mears — Episodes: "Shadows: Parts 1 & 2" • Heartbeat — Rose Brown — Episode: "The War of the Roses" • Wallander — Inga Wallander — Episode: "The Fifth Woman" • A — Christine Moorhead — Episodes: "If Dogs Run Free: Parts 1 & 2" • 2010, 2012 — Lip Service — Judy — Episodes: "1.4", "2.2" • 2010–2015 — Downton Abbey — Elsie May Carson (Mrs. Hughes) — Regular role • 2012 — Vera — Shirley — Episode: "A Certain Samaritan" • 2014 — Bones — Sandra Zins — Episode: "The Lost Love in the Foreign Land" • 2017–2018 — The — Maggie Smart — Main role (series 1), guest (series 2) • 2018 — Girlfriends — Linda Hutchinson — Main role • Doctor Who — Andinio — Episode: "The Battle of Ranskoor Av Kolos" • 2019–2025 — The — Mrs. Bird — Voice • 2020 — Our Queen at War — Narrator — TV movie documentary • The — Narrator — TV documentary series • 2021 — Intergalactic — Phoebe Skov-King — Episode: 1.5 • Ladybaby — Sheena Dunbar • Guilt — Maggie Lynch — Series 2 and 3 • 2024 — Shetland — Grace Bain — Series 8 • 2025 — Miss Austen — Mrs. Cassandra Austen — Series 1 • The Bombing of Pan Am 103 — Moira Shearer — TV miniseries, 6 episodes • Murder Most Puzzling — Cora Felton — Crime drama, 6 episodes • 2026 — A Taste For Murder — Elena Da Vinale — 6 episodes
Radio appearances
Radio appearances
• Baggage as Fiona • Coming Alive on BBC Radio 4 • BBC Radio Shakespeare: Macbeth (Dramatised) on BBC Radio 3 as Lady Macbeth • R.L. Stevenson's Weir Of Hermiston on BBC Radio 4 as Kirstie • Classic BBC Radio Horror: Dracula on BBC Radio 4 • Dr Finlay: Adventures of a Black Bag on BBC Radio 4
Selected stage roles
Selected stage roles
• Year — Title — Role — Theatre • 1980 — The Case of David Anderson Q. C. — Traverse Theatre, Edinburgh • Threads — Bernadette — Hampstead Theatre • 1983 — The Communication Cord — Susan — Hampstead Theatre • 1993 — Marvin's Room — Lee Wakefield Lacker — Hampstead Theatre and Comedy Theatre, London • 1994 — Gaucho — Steph/Stephanie — Hampstead Theatre • 2002 — Richard III — Queen Elizabeth — Crucible Theatre, Sheffield • 2008 — 2000 Feet Away — Nan — Bush Theatre • 2016 — Present Laughter — Monica Reed — Richmond Theatre • 2018 — Switzerland — Patricia Highsmith — Ambassadors Theatre, London and Theatre Royal, Bath
Identity
Identity
Phyllis Logan is recorded as having received Screen Actors Guild Award for Outstanding Performance by an Ensemble in a Drama Series and BAFTA Award for Most Promising Newcomer to Leading Film Roles.
Film
• Year — Title — Role — Notes • 1983 — Another Time, Another Place — Janie — BAFTA Award for Most Promising Newcomer to Leading Film Roles Evening Standard British Film Award for Best Actress Rimini Film Festival Award for Best Actress Taormina Film Fest Golden Mask Award Nominated – BAFTA Award for Best Actress in a Leading Role Nominated – David di Donatello for Best Foreign Actress • Every Picture Tells a Story — Agnes Scott • 1984 — The — Alison • Nineteen Eighty-Four — Telescreen Announcer — Voice • 1985 — The — Elizabeth Rock • 1987 — The — Claudia Procula • The — Janet Graham • 1989 — The — Mary Welsh • The — Mary Penrys Jones • 1990 — The — Camilla Staffa • 1992 — Freddie as F.R.O.7. — Nessie (voice) • Soft Top Hard Shoulder — Karla • 1993 — Franz Kafka's It's a Wonderful Life — Frau Brunofsky — Short film • 1996 — Secrets & Lies — Monica Purley • 1997 — Shooting Fish — Mrs. Ross • 2003 — Crust — Bill's Girlfriend • 2009 — Nativity! — Mrs. Lore • 2012 — Day of the Flowers — Brenda • 2019 — Downton Abbey — Elsie Hughes-Carson • 2020 — Misbehaviour — Evelyn Alexander • 2021 — The Last Bus — Mary • Last Train to Christmas — Auntie Vi • 2022 — Downton Abbey: A New Era — Elsie Hughes-Carson • Rocketry: The Nambi Effect — Mrs. Cleaver • 2023 — Surprised by Oxford — Provost Regina Knight • 2024 — No Way Up — Mardy 'Nana' • 2025 — Downton Abbey: The Grand Finale — Elsie Hughes-Carson
Recognition and collections
Where the work is held
Recognition and collections
Phyllis Logan received Screen Actors Guild Award for Outstanding Performance by an Ensemble in a Drama Series and BAFTA Award for Most Promising Newcomer to Leading Film Roles.
Documents and archives
Primary material
Documents and archives
reference work
- “Phyllis Logan”, English Wikipedia, consulted as further reading
Reputable secondary · Wikipedia
authority record
- Wikidata, structured authority record Q117995: Phyllis Logan
Unverified · Wikidata
Awards and nominations
In addition to the role-related awards listed below, Logan is 2023 winner of the St Andrew's Society of New York's Mark Twain Award in honour of her significant and positive impact on the Scots community around the world. • Year — Association — Category — Nominated work — Result • 1983 — Taormina Film Fest — Golden Mask — Another Time, Another Place • 1984 — Rimini Film Festival — Best Actress — Another Time, Another Place • Evening Standard British Film Awards — Best Actress — Another Time, Another Place • British Academy Film Awards — Best Actress — Another Time, Another Place • British Academy Film Awards — Most Outstanding Newcomer to Film — Another Time, Another Place • 1986 — David di Donatello Awards — Best Foreign Actress — Another Time, Another Place • 1991 — British Academy Television Awards — Scotland — Scotland — Actress in 1991 — The Play On One: And The Cow Jumped Over The Moon • 2012 — Screen Actors Guild Award — Outstanding Performance by an Ensemble in a Drama Series — Downton Abbey • 2013 — Screen Actors Guild Award — Outstanding Performance by an Ensemble in a Drama Series — Downton Abbey • 2014 — Screen Actors Guild Award — Outstanding Performance by an Ensemble in a Drama Series — Downton Abbey • 2015 — Screen Actors Guild Award — Outstanding Performance by an Ensemble in a Drama Series — Downton Abbey • 2016 — Screen Actors Guild Award — Outstanding Performance by an Ensemble in a Drama Series — Downton Abbey • The National Trust for Scotland Foundation USA — Great Scot Award — Herself • 2017 — Screen Actors Guild Award — Outstanding Performance by an Ensemble in a Drama Series — Downton Abbey • 2021 — New York International Women's Festival — Best Ensemble Acting in a Film — You Really Got Me • 2022 — British Academy Scotland Awards — Best Actress — Television — Guilt • Tweetfest Film Festival — Best Actress — Harold & Mary • 2024 — Royal Television Society Scotland — Best Female Actor — Shetland
Notes from the source article
Cited by Wikipedia
Notes from the source article
These works are cited by the source article, in its own numbering. They are recorded as its citations, not as sources VALÉORINE has verified.
- 1.British Film Institute. Phyllis Logan.
- 2.10 reasons why Paisley is already a city of culture. BBC News. 13 November 2015.
- 3.Video: Downton Abbey star from Refrewshire takes part in one-legged wobble challenge. Evening Times. 6 December 2015.
- 4.Paton Maguire, Maureen. Phyllis Logan: 'I never confided in my parents. My generation didn't do that'. The Guardian. 3 February 2017.
- 5.Renfrewshire Council – Education. The Scotsman. 24 April 2008.
- 6.My Scotland. Scotland in Trust. 23. 49921348.
- 7.The National Trust for Scotland Foundation USA. Celebration of Scotland's Treasures.
- 8.James Scott official site. Every Picture Tells a Story. 20 December 1984.
- 9.Shaw, Ann. Phyllis Logan Sets the Film World Buzzing. The Glasgow Herald. 1 August 1983.
- 10.Walker-Arnott, Ellie. Mrs Hughes is the best Downton Abbey character of all time. 28 September 2014.
- 11.Whittle, Nathalie. Phyllis Logan: "I'd Be Terrible In A Medical Crisis!". Woman & Home. 8 February 2017.
- 12.Girlfriends is about women of a certain age, which is nice to be involved with, says Phyllis Logan. The Sunday Post. 2 January 2018.
- 13.Downton's Phyllis Logan: Women are usually an 'appendage' on screen. Sutton & Croydon Guardian. 3 January 2018.
- 14.BBC. Coming Soon, Series 11, Doctor Who – BBC One. 7 October 2018.
- 15.Willis, Ciaran. Who is Doctor Who series finale guest star Phyllis Logan?. Radio Times.
- 16.BBC. New cast confirmed for Guilt as filming begins on the second series of BBC Two and BBC Scotland's multi award-winning drama. 25 November 2020.
- 17.BAFTA Scotland Awards 2022: Full List of Winners. BAFTA. 20 November 2022.
- 18.Robinson, Abby. Murder Most Puzzling Release date and schedule Radio Times. www.radiotimes.com.
- 19.Mwitumwa, By Monde. Downton Abbey actress joins real life husband on-screen in Channel 5 crime drama. The Mirror. 2025-07-05.
- 20.Shetland star Phyllis Logan's famous husband revealed. Hello!.
- 21.Scougall, Murray. Downton Abbey's Phyllis Logan on a sequel, feminism protests, the struggle facing theatres, and her love of animals. The Sunday Post. 23 June 2020.
- 22.Gm, Level Magazine-. Downton Abbey's Phyllis Logan's Lorraine interview interrupted by husband in his dressing gown. LEVEL MAGAZINE. 2020-06-19.
- 23.Jim Broadbent and Phyllis Logan feature in charity video about dementia carers. Evening Express (Scotland). 16 June 2020.
- 24.ITV. Phyllis Logan's charity work with dementia.
- 25.Downton Abbey star named as Scottish charity ambassador. The Scotsman. 30 March 2016.
- 26.Scottish SPCA holds event backed by Downton Abbey's Phyllis Logan. scottishspca.org. 12 March 2020.
- 27.The White Bird Passes (1980). British Film Institute.
- 28.Beginnings (1981). British Film Institute.
- 29.BBC. BBC Programme Index. January 1983.
- 30.Obituary: Rikki Fulton. The Guardian. 30 January 2004.
- 31.British Film Institute. Out of Time (1987).
- 32.British Film Institute. When Reason Sleeps: Out Of Time.
- 33.BBC. BBC Programme Index. 15 August 1991.
- 34.BBC. BBC Programme Index. 29 August 1991.
- 35.The Game (1998). British Film Institute.
- 36.ITV. ITV Press Centre — Our Queen at War.
- 37.Highland vets reveal life on the frontline in new documentary. The Press and Journal (Scotland). 14 June 2020.
- 38.Broadcaster Jeremy Vine reveals he's a fan of The Highland Vet. The Northern Times. 26 June 2020.
- 39.BBC. BBC Three — Ladybaby.
- 40.Szalai, Georg. 'Suits' Star Patrick J. Adams, Connor Swindells, Merritt Wever Cast in Netflix, BBC Series 'Lockerbie'. The Hollywood Reporter. 5 March 2024.
- 41.Murder Most Puzzling: Release date, cast, plot, trailer and latest news. radiotimes.com.
- 42.Baggage. comedy.co.uk.
- 43.Donaldson, Brian. Baggage. The List. 29 November 2007.
- 44.BBC. Coming Alive.
- 45.BBC. Drama on 3: Macbeth. 20 November 2005.
- 46.BBC. R.L. Stevenson's Weir Of Hermiston.
- 47.BBC. Bram Stoker's Dracula.
- 48.BBC. BBC Radio 4 Extra — Doctor Finlay: Adventures of a Black Bag.
- 49.Taylor, Paul. THEATRE / Sympathy for the devil: Gaucho — Hampstead Theatre. Independent. 24 October 1994.
- 50.Fisher, Philip. 2000 Feet Away — Anthony Weigh — Bush Theatre (2008). British Theatre Guide.
- 51.Present Laughter. 1 August 2016.
- 52.Downton Abbey's Phyllis Logan to lead glittering cast in Noel Coward's Present Laughter at Richmond Theatre. Sutton & Croydon Guardian. 6 July 2016.
- 53.Switzerland starring Phyllis Logan to transfer to the West End. WhatsOnStage.com. 23 August 2018.
- 54.267th Annual Banquet — Saint Andrew's Society of the State of NY. standrewsny.org.
- 55.Mystery, Intrigue, and History New York Social Diary. New York Social Diary. 2023-12-08.
- 56.Scotland — Actress in 1991. BAFTA.
- 57.Downton star helps raises $400,000 for National Trust for Scotland. The Scotsman. 22 April 2016.
- 58.BAFTA Scotland Awards 2022: Full List of Winners. BAFTA. 20 November 2022.
- 59.Phyllis Logan recognised for Shetland Performance at RTS. Silverprint Pictures. 3 July 2024.
References
Citations
References
Each reference names the institution holding it, so a reader may go to the document itself.
reference work
Partially resolvedauthority record
Unverified
People, houses and institutions
Knowledge graph
People, houses and institutions
Teachers, collaborators, publishers and institutions recorded against this person, each on a stated basis.
Studied at
1- Royal Conservatoire of ScotlandOrganisation
Established from a fact already recorded on a verified source.
The Encyclopedia exists whether or not anything is for sale. Corrections are recorded rather than overwritten, and every version of this record is kept. Published 14 August 2026.
Elsewhere in Film memorabilia
37,408 published records in this field, each with its sources named.
- Phyllis HaverPerson
- Phyllis Hodges BoycePerson
- Phyllis HymanPerson
- Phyllis KonstamPerson
- Phyllis NagyPerson
- Phyllis NewmanPerson
- Phyllis SomervillePerson
- Pia BajpieePerson
Best supported in this field
For owners
Own a work by Phyllis Logan?
A specialist will read what you send and tell you what the house can establish, what it cannot, and whether the object is suited to sale. There is no charge and no obligation. The object stays with you throughout; nothing is shipped to us unless it is arranged in writing beforehand.