Jim Gaffigan

Gaffigan is known for his unique brand of humor, which often addresses fatherhood, laziness, food, religion, and general observations. He is regarded as a "clean" comic, using little profanity in his routines, although he does use it from time to time. He has released thirteen successful long-form comedy specials. Gaffigan is also an actor, appearing in comedic and dramatic roles in film, television and on Broadway. He is married to actress, producer and writer Jeannie Gaffigan, with whom he has five children.

• Name — Jim Gaffigan • Birth Name — James Christopher Gaffigan • Born — 7 July 1966 • Birthplace — Elgin, Illinois, U.S. • Medium — * Stand-up • television • film • books • Active — 1991–present • Education — Georgetown University (BS) • Genre — * Observational comedy • clean comedy • deadpan • sarcasm • satire • Subjects — * American culture • religion • obesity • everyday life • marriage • social awkwardness • Relatives — Richard F. Mitchell (grandfather) • Children — 5 • Website — jimgaffigan.com

Gaffigan was born on July 7, 1966, in Elgin, Illinois. He is the youngest of six children, born to charity worker and fundraiser Marcia Miriam (née Mitchell) and banker Michael Ambrose Gaffigan. Of Irish descent, his family's surname was Gavahan. His maternal grandfather was Iowa Supreme Court Justice Richard F. Mitchell. Gaffigan was raised in Chesterton in Northwest Indiana, a region that he has stated influenced his comedy because of its authenticity, and often jokes about growing up in a large family. His mother was accomplished at needlework and received a national award for original design and craftsmanship from the American Needlepoint Guild in 1985. She died of cancer in 1990 at age 53. Gaffigan's father was the president and CEO of the Mercantile National Bank of Indiana for 15 years until his retirement in 1991. A former seminarian, he was also actively involved in local charity work. He died of lung cancer in 1999. Gaffigan's father was the first in his family to attend college, and encouraged his children to seek careers that promised job security. However, at about the age of five, Gaffigan announced that he wanted to be an actress unaware that it was the female noun for the occupation. As a teenager, Gaffigan watched Saturday Night Live and Late Night with David Letterman. He attended La Lumiere School in La Porte, Indiana, where he played on the school's football team. He attended Purdue University for one year, where he was a member of the Phi Gamma Delta fraternity, before transferring to Georgetown University's McDonough School of Business, where he graduated in 1988 with a degree in finance. Although he "hated" studying finance, he worked as a litigation consultant for a short time after graduating and "was horrible at it". He played football at Georgetown and Purdue.

• Illustration — Gaffigan performing in May 2008 Gaffigan moved to New York in 1990 to work in advertising, initially as an assistant account executive before switching to copywriting. A co-worker encouraged him to take an improv class to deal with fears surrounding public speaking. His stand-up career launched after a friend from his improv class dared him to take a stand-up seminar that required a live set at the end. Gaffigan fell in love with stand-up, and began playing comedy clubs nightly. At the start of his career, Gaffigan worked a full-time day job, took acting classes at night, and did stand-up until the early hours of the morning. He was often found sleeping at his day job; his boss had to wake him up to fire him. For the first couple years of Gaffigan's stand-up career, he tried various styles, ranging from angry comedy to impressions and voices. After auditioning for The Late Show with David Letterman for six years, Gaffigan booked a spot on the show, did a successful stand-up routine on the show in 1999, and his career took off.

In October 2005, Gaffigan filmed his first hour-long comedy special for Comedy Central that aired the following January, and became the comedy album/DVD Beyond the Pale. The special/album/DVD included material regarding food and American eating habits; the comedian unknowingly predicted a future menu item at Dunkin' Donuts—the "glazed donut breakfast sandwich"—while commenting on the future of America's eating habits. His 2009 album King Baby was also a television special for Comedy Central filmed in Austin, Texas. On February 25, 2012, Gaffigan taped a one-hour stand-up special—Mr. Universe—at the Warner Theater in Washington, D.C.; it was nominated for a Grammy. He announced that, based on the business model used by Louis C.K.'s Live at the Beacon Theater, Mr. Universe would be available online through his website for $5, with 20% of the total proceeds going to the Bob Woodruff Foundation, an organization that provides support to military veterans. In 2012, he was among the top-ten grossing comics in the US, according to Pollstar. In 2014, Gaffigan was named the "King of Clean" by the Wall Street Journal. Gaffigan filmed his 2014 comedy special titled Jim Gaffigan: Obsessed at Boston's Wilbur Theater on January 18, 2014. Obsessed premiered on Comedy Central on April 27 becoming the most watched stand-up comedy special of the year for the network. The accompanying album, also titled Obsessed, debuted at number 11 on the Billboard 200 and number 1 on the Billboard Comedy Album charts. 2015 saw him embark on a headlining tour, culminating in a sold-out show at Madison Square Garden. Gaffigan has also pioneered exploring new and different platforms for his comedy specials. He was one of the first comedians to experiment with limited theatrical and website releases of comedy specials. He had the first original stand-up comedy special released on Amazon Prime Video (Noble Ape, 2018) and Hulu (The Skinny, 2024). On July 29, 2020, Gaffigan was announced as the first stand-up comic to hit over one billion streams on Pandora.com. Also that year, Gaffigan’s Pale Tourist, a compilation of 4 short comedy specials shot in or about different countries/parts of the world premiered on Amazon Prime video. Gaffigan’s 9th special, Comedy Monster, which streamed on Netflix, was nominated for a 2023 Grammy Award. His 10th comedy special, 2023's Dark Pale, was met with critical fanfare with The New York Times calling it, “his best yet.” Gaffigan co-headlined with Jerry Seinfeld a sold-out multi-city arena tour, including two shows at The Hollywood Bowl during the Netflix Is Joke Festival. On November 23, 2025, Gaffigan released Live from Old Forester—The Bourbon Set as a surprise drop on his YouTube channel, which has garnered 4.8 million views. The bourbon-centric long form comedy special was filmed at The Kentucky Center for the Performing Arts in Louisville and is entirely about whiskey. Gaffigan has described the show as a passion project stemming from his recent obsession with bourbon and love for the whiskey community.

Gaffigan has performed stand-up to support charitable causes as well. In 2002, he was part of a United Service Organization event at Guantanamo Bay Naval Base. Gaffigan performed at the 2013 Stand Up for Heroes charity event benefitting the Bob Woodruff Foundation alongside fellow stand-up comedians Jerry Seinfeld, Bill Cosby and Jon Stewart. Gaffigan also performed at the 2013 CNN Heroes event, which celebrates everyday heroes doing extraordinary work around the world. In May 2014, Gaffigan performed at the Make It Right Gala, an organization founded by Brad Pitt, which builds sustainable homes and buildings for communities in need. On September 26, 2015, he performed at the Festival of Families, a Catholic event held in Philadelphia. Gaffigan was the only comedian on the bill at the festival, and the event was visited by Pope Francis. The event had more than one million attendees. Gaffigan has hosted The Al Smith Memorial Dinner multiple times. In October 2024, Gaffigan roasted President Trump and an absent Vice President Kamala Harris.

Gaffigan's style is largely observational. Some of his main topics are laziness, eating and parenthood. His famous Hot Pocket routine was inspired by a commercial he saw that he mistook for a Saturday Night Live sketch. Gaffigan often “talks for the audience” or uses an “inside voice". For example, in a high-pitched voice, he may portray someone giving negative feedback on his own performance. After he made a diarrhea joke in his 2012 special "Mr. Universe", he used the voice to say, "Really, he's using diarrhea jokes?" He has said, "That inside voice is my connection with the audience". In an interview with the Duluth News-Tribune, he explained that he began developing the voice as a teenager, when he disarmed people by talking for them in their presence. He said he also used it to fend off hecklers earlier in his career, when comedy clubs were more "combative". He cursed early in his career, and added cursing to his comedy album Doing My Time at the request of his label, in the hopes of drawing more teens. He removed profanity from his routine, as he feels his subject matter doesn't lend itself to cursing and it reduced the effort he put into crafting his jokes. Gaffigan’s stand-up writing is characterized by single topic thoroughness. He discusses and dissects a topic for long stretches of time. These topics can range from bacon to horses to teenagers. Gaffigan has performed entire comedy specials such as Pale Tourist and Live from Old Forester—The Bourbon Set solely focused on single topics.

After his first appearance on The Late Show with David Letterman in 1999, Gaffigan was tapped by the host to develop a sitcom called Welcome to New York in which he also co-starred alongside Christine Baranski. The show was cancelled after its first season, despite positive reviews. During the 2000/2001 TV season, he was a cast member of The Ellen Show on CBS, Ellen DeGeneres's second sitcom. Gaffigan was a recurring character on That '70s Show, and Ed before becoming a regular cast member of the TBS original sitcom My Boys, which he left at the end of its third season. He appeared on multiple Law & Order episodes and spinoffs of the show. These include "Flight" and "Reality Bites", and in the "Smile" episode Law & Order: Criminal Intent. In 2009, Gaffigan guest-starred as the best friend of Murray Hewitt in an episode of the HBO comedy series Flight of the Conchords. Gaffigan was in an episode of The Daily Show as a man posing as a Daily Show correspondent who knows nothing about the show (he refers to it as "The John Daily Show") and just wants to be seen with Jon Stewart. It was meant as a parody of the 2009 White House gatecrash incident. Gaffigan co-created and starred in the TV Land series The Jim Gaffigan Show. In the 2010s, Gaffigan, his wife, and Peter Tolan began to develop material for a show based loosely on their own life. CBS agreed to shoot a pilot of their show in March 2013 but ultimately passed on the project. TV Land acquired the rights in an effort to broadcast original material and attract younger audiences, and it offered the Gaffigans complete creative control. The result was The Jim Gaffigan Show, a sitcom about a couple raising their five kids in a two-bedroom New York City apartment. After the release of two online-only episodes in June 2015, the pilot episode aired on July 15, 2015. The show stars Gaffigan as a fictionalized version of himself, with his wife Jeannie played by Ashley Williams. Other characters include their real-estate agent and Jeannie's best friend Daniel (played by Michael Ian Black), Jim's fellow comic and best friend Dave (Adam Goldberg), and their priest, Father Nicholas (Tongayi Chirisa). After 2 seasons of the show, in 2016 Jim and his wife Jeannie decided not to continue with a third season so they could spend more time with their five young children. In October 2016, it was announced Gaffigan would be joining the cast of the third season of the anthology drama series Fargo. However, he was ultimately forced to drop out due to scheduling difficulties; he was replaced by Mark Forward. In 2024, Gaffigan began appearing on Saturday Night Live to portray Democratic nominee for vice president Tim Walz. His portrayal of Walz was widely praised. Gaffigan appears as President Grover Cleveland in the fourth season of HBO's The Gilded Age.

As a struggling stand-up comedian in the 1990s, a friend suggested Gaffigan audition for commercials, a move that turned out to be profitable. He has appeared in over 200 TV commercial campaigns, ranging from Rolling Rock to Saturn to ESPN. His ubiquity earned him the title of 'Salesman of the Year' by BusinessWeek in 1999. He also performed in a trio of Sierra Mist commercials for the 2007 Super Bowl as part of the comedy ensemble "The Mis-Takes" which included Tracy Morgan and Michael Ian Black. In February 2016, Gaffigan began appearing in KFC commercials as Colonel Sanders, replacing Norm Macdonald. In April 8, 2016, Gaffigan appeared with his family in a marketing campaign for the 2017 Chrysler Pacifica.

Gaffigan is also noted for his voice-over work. In a series of animated shorts for Late Night with Conan O'Brien titled Pale Force (2005 to 2008), Gaffigan wrote, produced and voiced all the characters. The animated sketches featured Gaffigan and O'Brien as superheroes who fight crime with their extremely pale skin. The series was nominated for a Daytime Emmy in 2007 in the category of Outstanding Broadband Program–Comedy. Gaffigan has also voiced characters on the animated shows Bob's Burgers, Rick and Morty, Shorty McShorts' Shorts, WordGirl, and Star vs. the Forces of Evil. Animated feature films include the Pixar film Luca, Hotel Transylvania, Duck Duck Goose, and Playmobil: The Movie.

Gaffigan appeared on Broadway in That Championship Season, which opened in March 2011, opposite Brian Cox, Chris Noth, Kiefer Sutherland, and Jason Patric. ABC News correspondent Sandy Kenyon praised his performance as "the most moving" and said that he "may steal the show". Gaffigan called being on Broadway "an amazing experience, really hard but really fun". In December 2025 Gaffigan returned to Broadway in All Out: Comedy About Ambition which involved a rotating star-studded ensemble.

• Illustration — Gaffigan in 2008 Gaffigan's humorous quips have earned him over two and a half million followers on Twitter. He was listed by Rolling Stone as one of the "25 funniest people on Twitter" in 2012.

Gaffigan contributed short humorous commentaries to the CBS Sunday Morning show, which earned Gaffigan three Emmy awards. These commentaries mainly addressed parenting and slice of life topics. Gaffigan's columns and style was often compared favoriably to Andy Rooney's 60 Minutes commentaries.

Gaffigan sometimes writes with his wife, Jeannie Gaffigan. Prior to meeting his wife, actress Jeannie Noth, Gaffigan largely wrote alone. However, while working on his first show, Welcome to New York, he was overwhelmed and asked for input from her (then his girlfriend). Although initially hesitant to have a collaborator, as their relationship grew, so did Noth's ability to write material for him. Once they married, she left behind her work with her youth theater project (Shakespeare on the Playground) to devote herself to raising their expanding brood, and after a joke she wrote drew big laughs at a show, she and Jim began to collaborate more. She gradually transferred into the position of writing partners on select projects. She has been a credited writer and/or executive producer on some comedy specials, including his two books and television show. He also credits her with "coaching" him through his performance in That Championship Season.

In 2024, Gaffigan launched his own bourbon whiskey company, Fathertime Bourbon, with his college friend, Stu Pollard. Named for the "occasional brief period of peace and reflection every hardworking father earns" with a label that features Gaffigan's paternal grandfather, Fathertime is a high-rye expression. Fathertime Bourbon has received many accolades and won the Best New Bourbon award in the 2026 San Francisco World Spirits competition. Gaffigan is heavily involved in every aspect of the Fathertime business, including sampling and choosing all the barrels that eventually get bottled.

• Illustration — Jim Gaffigan at the 2025 Tribeca Festival Gaffigan married actress Jeannie Gaffigan (née Noth) in 2003. They have two daughters and three sons. All children were home births in their two bedroom apartment in New York City. His oldest child, Marre, was born on May 2, 2004. The second child, Jack, was born on November 27, 2005. Their third child, Katie Louise, was born on May 10, 2009. Their fourth child, Michael, was born on June 19, 2011. Their youngest child, Patrick was born on September 27, 2012. The family of seven lived in a two-bedroom apartment in the Manhattan borough of New York City before moving to a larger Manhattan apartment in 2015. To stay connected to his family, Gaffigan tries to "maintain bedtime rituals while working in the city". When on tour, he reportedly often takes his family with him. His son, Jack, has opened for his father's shows on occasion. Gaffigan is a practicing Catholic and has said he avoids working on Sundays, though he has joked that his wife is so much more devout than him that she seems like a "Shiite Catholic" in comparison. He and his family attend Mass at St. Patrick's Old Cathedral in Manhattan, which is also where he and his wife were married and where their children were baptized. In May 2016, he and his wife delivered the commencement address at the Catholic University of America. They also delivered the commencement address at his wife's alma mater, Marquette University, in May 2018. They both received honorary Doctor of Humane Letters degrees as part of the graduation ceremony. In 2019, Gaffigan apologized on social media after endorsing the "Moriori First" myth in one of his stand-up shows. The myth falsely claims that Māori displaced the Moriori as the first people of New Zealand, and has been used to justify white settler colonialism. Gaffigan also made disparaging remarks about Māori people, which were described as "offensive" and "ignorant" on New Zealand social media.

• YEAR — TITLE — LENGTH — RELEASED ON — STREAMING — RECORDED AT — NOTES • 2000 — Comedy Central Presents: Jim Gaffigan — 24 minutes — Comedy Central — Paramount Plus — New York • 2001 — Luigi's Doghouse — 42 minutes — Self-released album — Album Only — New York — 15 tracks • Economics II — 27 minutes — Self-released album — Album Only — New York — 8 tracks • 2003 — More Moo Moos — 51minutes — Self-released album — Album Only — New York — 23 tracks • 2004 — The Last Supper — 52 minutes — Self-released album — Album Only — New York — 29 tracks • 2004 — Doing My Time — 63 minutes — Comedy Central Records — Album Only — Giggle's Comedy Club, Seattle — 13 tracks plus special features • 2006 — Beyond The Pale — 72 minutes — Comedy Central — Netflix — Chicago's Vic Theatre • 2009 — King Baby — 72 minutes — Comedy Central — Netflix — Austin's Paramount Theatre • 2012 — Mr. Universe — 77 minutes — jimgaffigan.com — Netflix — DC's Warner Theatre — Grammy nomination • 2014 — Obsessed — 70 minutes — Theatrical release — Netflix — Boston's Wilbur Theatre — Grammy nomination • 2017 — Cinco — 73 minutes — Netflix — Netflix — Palace Theatre, Columbus, OH — Grammy nomination • 2018 — Noble Ape — 70 minutes — Amazon Prime — Amazon Prime — Boston's Wilbur Theatre — Grammy nomination • 2019 — Quality Time — 75 minutes — Comedy Central — Amazon Prime — State Theatre — Grammy nomination • 2020 — The Pale Tourist — 45 minutes — Amazon Prime — Amazon Prime — Center in the Square, Kitchener, Ontario, Canada — Grammy Nomination • The Pale Tourist/Spanish-American — 50 minutes — Amazon Prime — Amazon Prime — Club Capital, Barcelona, Spain • The Pale Tourist/Asian- American — 26 minutes — Featured on The Pale Album only — YouTube — Ewha Women's University Samsung Hall, Seoul, Korea — Recorded while on International tour • The Pale Tourist/Florida Man — 14 minutes — Featured on The Pale Album only — YouTube • 2021 — Comedy Monster — 70 minutes — Netflix — Netflix — Boston's Wilbur Theatre — Grammy Nomination • 2022 — Dark Pale — 64 minutes — Amazon Prime — Amazon Prime — Straz Center — People's Choice Nomination for Favorite Comedian • 2023 — The Prisoner — 44 minutes — Comedy Dynamics — Album Only — Grammy Nomination • 2024 — The Skinny — 61 minutes — Hulu — Hulu — Boston's Wilbur Theatre • 2025 — Live from Old Forrester—The Bourbon Set — 44 minutes — YouTube — YouTube — Kentucky Center

• Year — Title — Role — Notes • 1998 — Soul Man — Keats — Episode: "Raising Heck" • Dr. Katz, Professional Therapist — Jim — Episode: "Old Man" • 1998, 2009 — Law & Order — Larry Johnson / George Rozakis — 2 episodes • 1998 — Conrad Bloom — Oliver — Episode: "How Florrie Got Her Groove Back" • 1999 — LateLine — The Del-Ex Kid — Episode: "Pearce on Conan" • 2000 — Third Watch — Portis — Episode: "Journey to the Himalayas" • Comedy Central Presents — Jim Gaffigan — 1 episode • Cry Baby Lane — Dan — Television film • 2000–01 — Welcome to New York — Jim Gaffigan — 13 episodes • 2001 — Law & Order: Special Victims Unit — Oliver Tunney — Episode: "Countdown" • Sex and the City — Doug — Episode: "Defining Moments" • 2001–02 — The Ellen Show — Rusty Carnouk — 18 episodes • 2002 — Law & Order: Criminal Intent — Marty Palin / Russell Matthews — 2 episodes • 2003 — Hope & Faith — Brad — Episode: "Anger Management" • 2003–04 — Ed — Toby Gibbons — 4 episodes • That '70s Show — Roy Keene — 7 episodes • 2004 — Bad Apple — Butters — Television film • Strip Search — Reverend Craig Peterson • The Jury — Mr. Nifco — Episode: "Mail Order Mystery" • 2005 — Cheap Seats — Jerome Block — Episode: "Gimmick Sports" • 2006 — Love, Inc. — Jamie — Episode: "Anything But Love" • Shorty McShorts' Shorts — Og, Henrichven (voice) — Episode: "My Mom Married A Yeti" • 2006–09 — My Boys — Andy Franklin — 40 episodes • 2009 — Flight of the Conchords — Jim — Episode: "Murray Takes It to the Next Level" • WordGirl — Mr. Dudley (voice) — 3 episodes • 2010 — Bored to Death — Drug Counsellor — Episode: "Super Ray Is Mortal!" • 2011 — Royal Pains — Pete Stanbleck — Episode: "Astraphobia" • 2012–13 — Portlandia — Donald — 2 episodes • 2013–24 — Bob's Burgers — Henry Haber (voice) — 7 episodes • 2014 — Us & Them — Theo — 2 episodes • 2015 — Wallykazam! — Mr. Trollman (voice) — Episode: "Rock and Troll" • 2015–19 — Star vs. the Forces of Evil — Father Time / additional voices — 3 episodes • 2015–16 — The Jim Gaffigan Show — Himself — 23 episodes; also co-creator, writer, executive producer • 2016 — Comedians in Cars Getting Coffee — Himself — Episode: "Stick Around for the Pope" • 2017 — Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt — Officer Krupke — Episode: "Kimmy Bites an Onion!" • | Gilbert — Himself — Documentary • 2019 — Scooby-Doo and Guess Who? — Himself (voice) — Episode: "The Fastest Fast Food Fiend!" • 2021 — Stargirl — Thunderbolt (voice) — 2 episodes • Rick and Morty — Hoovy (voice) — Episode: "Mort Dinner Rick Andre" • 2022 — Reindeer in Here — Santa Claus (voice) — Television special • 2023 — Full Circle — Manny Broward — Miniseries • 2024 — Jersey Shore: Family Vacation — Himself — Episode: "Jets Day" • Hit-Monkey — Snail (voice) — Episode: "Never Too Late" • Saturday Night Live — Tim Walz — 4 episodes

Gaffigan earned the nickname "King of Sundance" in 2019 when three of his feature films (Troop Zero, Them That Follow, and Light From Light) premiered at the Sundance Film Festival. Gaffigan appeared in two movies chosen for the 2001 Sundance Film Festival: Super Troopers and 30 Years to Life. In 2023, Gaffigan was on the Sundance Film Festival Jury. Gaffigan appeared in the Sam Mendes–directed dramedy Away We Go and the teen comedy 17 Again. Gaffigan starred in Shia LaBeouf's 2013 short film Howard Cantour.com, the content of which was later revealed to be mostly plagiarized from Daniel Clowes's 2007 graphic novella Justin M. Damiano. Reflecting on the incident in an interview for The Daily Beast, Gaffigan said, "There's no greater sin in the stand-up world than thievery...So you do not want to be associated with thievery," but added, "I don't have any hard feelings about it because I don't think people think I had anything to do with it." In 2008, he appeared in the movie The Love Guru starring Mike Myers. Gaffigan co-starred in the film Experimenter, a fictionalized account of the experiments of the Yale professor Stanley Milgram. Gaffigan plays an actor hired to collaborate in the experiments. Gaffigan portrayed George Westinghouse in Michael Almereyda's 2020 film Tesla. In 2018, he portrayed Paul Markham in the biographical drama Chappaquiddick, starring Jason Clarke and Kate Mara, to positive reviews. Gaffigan next took on the lead role in the 2018 neo-noir film American Dreamer, which was released on September 20, 2019. Gaffigan's dark portrayal of a broken man driven to desperate actions was very well received by critics, with the Chicago Sun-Times review calling it "a career-best dramatic performance" by Gaffigan. In January 2021, he joined the cast of Disney's Peter Pan & Wendy as Mr. Smee directed by David Lowery. Lowery produced Light from Light and also directed Gaffigan in the animated short film, An Almost Christmas Story. Gaffigan co-starred in Colin West's Linoleum which Vulture placed on its Best Movies of 2023 list. Gaffigan was reunited with director Colin West on the film Outside of Cleveland, with Alex Wolff and Sarah Wayne Callies. In 2026, Gaffigan co-starred in Joshua Caldwell' s Three People In The Woods, with Katherine McPhee and Henry Thomas. He was also in Blaise Bayhan's New England Toys with Jennifer Jason Leigh and Jason Schwartzmann, and Crosshairs with Alec Baldwin directed by Mukunda Michael Dewil.

• Year — Title — Role — Notes • 1998 — The Real Howard Spitz — Storekeeper • 1999 — Personals — Waiter • Entropy — Bucky • Three Kings — Cuts Troy's Cuff Soldier • Puppet — Mr. Kamen • 2001 — Super Troopers — Larry Johnson • 30 Years to Life — Russell • Final — Dayton • 2002 — Hacks — Arty Hittle • No Sleep 'til Madison — Owen • Igby Goes Down — Hilton Manager • 2003 — Season of Youth — Dr. Gelding • 2004 — 13 Going on 30 — Chris Grandy • Duane Incarnate — Bob • 2005 — The Great New Wonderful — Sandie • Trust the Man — Gordon • 2006 — Stephanie Daley — Joe Daley • 2007 — The Living Wake — Lampert Binew • 2008 — The Love Guru — Trent Lueders • Shoot First and Pray You Live (Because Luck Has Nothing to Do with It) — Mart Ryder • 2009 — The Slammin' Salmon — Stanley Bellin • 17 Again — Coach Murphy • Away We Go — Lowell • 2010 — Ten Stories Tall — Simon • Going the Distance — Phil • It's Kind of a Funny Story — George • 2011 — Salvation Boulevard — Jerry Hobson • 2012 — Howard Cantour.com — Howard Cantour — Short film • 2013 — Kilimanjaro — Bill • 2015 — Walter — Corey • Experimenter — James McDonough • Hot Pursuit — Red • Staten Island Summer — Danny's Father • 2016 — Chuck — John Stoehr • 2017 — Chappaquiddick — Paul F. Markham • 2018 — Duck Duck Goose — Peng — Voice role • Being Frank — Frank Hansen • Super Troopers 2 — Larry Johnson • Hotel Transylvania 3: Summer Vacation — Abraham Van Helsing — Voice role • American Dreamer — Cam • 2019 — Them That Follow — Zeke Slaughter • Light from Light — Richard • Troop Zero — Ramsey • The Day Shall Come — Lemmy • Drunk Parents — Carl Mancini • Above the Shadows — Paul Jederman • Playmobil: The Movie — Del — Voice role • 2020 — Tesla — George Westinghouse • Most Wanted — Picker • 2021 — Luca — Lorenzo Paguro — Voice role • 2022 — Hotel Transylvania: Transformania — Abraham Van Helsing • Collide — Peter • Linoleum — Cameron Edwin/Kent Armstrong • Susie Searches — Sheriff Loggins • 2023 — Peter Pan & Wendy — Mr. Smee • 2024 — Unfrosted — Edsel Kellogg III • Greedy People — The Irishman • Running on Empty — Barry • An Almost Christmas Story — Papa Owl — Voice role; short film • 2025 — Maintenance Required — Mr. Miller

Gaffigan credits David Letterman and Bill Murray as influences, and has asserted that Richard Pryor was the greatest stand-up comedian ever. His comedy mentor was Dave Attell, who Gaffigan said was the only person who thought he was funny in his early stand-up years. On the episode of Comedians in Cars Getting Coffee featuring Gaffigan, he admitted that the show's host Jerry Seinfeld was a big influence for him.

Gaffigan is widely noted as an everyman and a clean comic; some of his signature routines regard Hot Pockets, cake, and bacon. One critic compared him to Full House-era Bob Saget (who starred in the 1990s family show), which Gaffigan took as an insult. Hampton Stevens in The Atlantic wrote that Gaffigan "champions a vital element to standup that [[Lenny Bruce|[Lenny] Bruce]] had taken away—the indispensable, but apparently forgotten idea that comedians have no obligation to be provocative, topical, socially conscious, or anything else but funny."

On April 26, 2014, Gaffigan received the award for Concert Comedian at the American Comedy Awards for his work. In 2007, Pale Force was nominated for a Daytime Emmy for Outstanding Broadband Program in the Comedy category. Gaffigan served as executive producer, writer, and lead actor. In 2016, he won the Daytime Emmy Award for Outstanding Morning Program for his contributions as a commentator to CBS Sunday Morning.

The Grammy Awards are awarded annually by the National Academy of Recording Arts and Sciences. Gaffigan has been nominated eight times. • Year — Category — Nominated work — Result — Ref. • 2013 — Best Comedy Album — Mr. Universe • 2015 — Obsessed • 2018 — Cinco • 2019 — Noble Ape • 2020 — Quality Time • 2021 — The Pale Tourist • 2023 — Comedy Monster • 2025 — The Prisoner