Whisper Me a Love Song
Also recorded as SasaKoi · Sasayaku Yō ni Koi wo Utau · Whispering You a Love Song · Sasayaku Yō ni Koi o Utau
Whisper Me a Love Song

©竹嶋えく・一迅社/ささやくように恋を唄う製作委員会 · https: sasakoi-anime.com · Public domain
- Name
- Whisper Me a Love Song
- Creator
- Eku Takeshima
- Date
- 2019
- Publisher
- Yuri Hime Comics · Kodansha USA Publishing and LLC
- Language
- Japanese
- Genre
- yuri · school anime and manga · band anime and manga
Reference Check
Propose documentary evidence for Whisper Me a Love Song. A contribution is never written directly as fact: identity, source, rights and evidence gates still decide.
Sign in to contribute
Documentary evidence
Documentary basis
Authority files
wikidata · Q85868900 · wikipedia · Whisper Me a Love Song
In this article
The object
The object
It is recorded as the work of Eku Takeshima. Publication is recorded by Yuri Hime Comics and Kodansha USA Publishing, LLC. The recorded date of publication is 2019. It is associated with Japan. Recorded genres are yuri, school anime and manga and band anime and manga.
Key facts
Key facts
• Name — Whisper Me a Love Song • Ja Kanji — ささやくように恋を唄う • Ja Romaji — Sasayaku Yō ni Koi o Utau • Genre — Yuri
Key facts
Key facts
• Type — manga • Author — Eku Takeshima • Publisher — Ichijinsha • Magazine — Comic Yuri Hime • First — February 18, 2019 • Volumes — 12 • Volume List — List of Whisper Me a Love Song chapters
Key facts
Key facts
• Type — tv series • Director — Akira Mano (1–10) • Writer — Hiroki Uchida • Music — * Hiroshi Sasaki • Wataru Maeguchi • Studio — * Yokohama Animation Laboratory • Cloud Hearts (1–10) • Licensee — Sentai Filmworks • Network — * ANN (TV Asahi) • BS Asahi, AT-X • First — April 14, 2024 • Last — December 29, 2024 • Episodes — 12 • Episode List — List of Whisper Me a Love Song episodes
Key facts
Key facts
• Portal — yes Whisper Me a Love Song is a Japanese manga series written and illustrated by Eku Takeshima. It was first serialized in Ichijinsha's Comic Yuri Hime April 2019 issue and is licensed in English by Kodansha Comics. The series follows Himari Kino, a first-year high school girl, and Yori Asanagi, a third-year high school girl in a band, after Himari's confession of admiration for Yori's singing leads to a romantic misunderstanding. Takeshima created the story based on the idea of a senpai- dynamic, a type of social relationship commonplace in Japanese culture. Afterwards, she worked in an element of miscommunication stemming from love at first sight, as well as a balanced relationship between the two leads as they evoked emotional reactions from each other. An anime television series adaptation produced by Cloud Hearts and Yokohama Animation Laboratory aired from April to December 2024 after numerous production delays. Several insert songs and two ending themes were created for the series. Takeshima helped supervise the audition process, and throughout recording, the voice actors aimed to portray their characters' personalities through their expression. In 2020, the manga series was nominated for Niconico and Da Vincis Next Manga Awards and selected as the winner of Yuri Navis Yuri Manga Awards. It had sold over one million copies by August 2024, and has been well received by critics, with praise for its story, characters, and themes of LGBTQ+ representation. The anime adaptation has received more mixed reviews, with positive comments for its plot but criticism for its production value.
Synopsis
Synopsis
On her first day of high school, Himari Kino watches her senior Yori Asanagi perform with a band and instantly falls in love with her singing. When Himari confesses her admiration to Yori, she misinterprets Himari's feelings as romantic love. However, she falls for Himari anyway and promises to win her affections for real after finding out the truth.
Characters
Characters
• Himari Kino • Hana Shimano • Yui Watanabe (actress) • A first-year high school student and energetic girl who falls in love with Yori's singing on her first day of school. She confesses her admiration to Yori, who misinterprets her feelings as romantic. Upon learning of Yori's true feelings for her, however, she eventually discovers that she loves Yori too and they become lovers. • Yori Asanagi • Asami Seto, Kana Sasakura (singing voice) • Momoka Ishii • A third-year high school student who serves as the vocalist and lead guitarist for the band SSGIRLS after their previous vocalist quit. Often seen as stoic, Yori enjoys singing alone while playing the guitar on the school's rooftop. Yori falls for Himari after her "confession", only to realize later that Himari was actually confessing admiration for her singing. However, she resolves to get Himari to reciprocate her feelings in time, and they eventually become lovers. • Aki Mizuguchi • Mikako Komatsu • Yuuki Temma • A cheerful third-year student and the bassist for SSGIRLS. She is Yori's best friend and tries to support her in winning over Himari while hiding her own romantic feelings for Yori. She had a falling out with the band's previous singer Shiho, who left the band on bad terms. After eventually learning that Shiho had romantic feelings for her and understanding how her feelings for Yori had changed, she makes up with Shiho and they become a couple. • Shiho Izumi • Yuna Nemoto, Sui Mizukami (singing voice) • Chiyuri Itō (singer) • A third-year student, and former vocalist and guitarist of SSGIRLS, which she left following a feud with Aki. She now fronts a rival band, Laureley, while also acting as a ghost member for the Culinary Research Club. It was later revealed that she had romantic feelings for Aki, becoming heartbroken upon discovering Aki had feelings for Yori and leaving the band as a result. Thanks to the efforts of Himari and others, however, she eventually manages to make up with Aki, who becomes her girlfriend. • Mari Tsutsui • Konomi Kohara • Nagisa Hayakawa • A stoic third-year student and the drummer for SSGIRLS. She comes from a rich background and is childhood friends with Kaori. She tends to refer to people by their full names. • Kaori Tachibana • Ai Kakuma • Nanase Kayama • An easygoing third-year student and the keyboardist for SSGIRLS. She has been friends with Mari since childhood. • Miki Mizuguchi • Aoi Koga • Yuuki Temma • Aki's younger sister and Himari's best friend since elementary school. She is part of the brass band club and tries to support Himari and Aki any way she can. • Momoka Satomiya • Reina Ueda • Shiori Nishikado • A kind-hearted second-year student who is the president of the Culinary Research Club and the guitarist for Laureley. Gentle and supportive, she quickly befriends Himari, who joins her club. • Hajime Amasawa • Chika Anzai • Kaede Sakuragi • A third-year student who is the drummer for Laureley. She is often seen with Momoka and is the younger sister of Momoka's late girlfriend Kyou. • Kyou Amasawa • Nao Tōyama • A violinist who was Hajime's older sister and Momoka's girlfriend. She was originally friends with Shiho until Shiho became jealous of her talent. She died in an accident, leading Shiho and the others to form Laureley.
Conception
Conception
Prior to creating Whisper Me a Love Song, Takeshima had already had experience in drawing yuri manga, having created several doujinshi fan works featuring yuri relationships. She had also previously published a one-shot story, I want you to say I love you, in Comic Yuri Hime. Takeshima has stated that she enjoys incorporating classic story tropes and is happiest when she can show characters being affectionate in these situations. Whisper Me a Love Song began with the idea of a senpai- dynamic, a type of social relationship commonplace in Japanese culture. However, after struggling to develop a full story from this premise, Takeshima decided to focus first on character design, eventually creating around twelve different character visuals. Yori's design was decided relatively quickly, whereas Himari's took more time to finalize.
Development
Development
According to Takeshima, once the character designs were established, the story developed more easily. Her editor suggested incorporating a misunderstanding stemming from love at first sight and having the senpai character play guitar, both of which were eventually worked into the plot. As serialization began, Takeshima found the first two chapters challenging, since they were published simultaneously and depicted the same scene of Himari and Yori meeting from both of their perspectives. Takeshima named her favorite scene as the panel where Himari falls in love with Yori after seeing her singing, which she redrew five times. In terms of characterization, Takeshima aimed to portray Himari as an outgoing and straightforward girl who tended to act directly on her feelings. However, to avoid Himari coming across as self-centered, she made sure to show how Himari is also thoughtful with her actions. Meanwhile, for Yori, she focused on creating a contrast between her outwardly cool and composed appearance and her inwardly softer, more emotionally vulnerable side. The relationship between Himari and Yori was designed to be balanced, with each character alternately taking the lead and evoking emotional reactions in the other. Following the manga's publication, Takeshima said that one of her happiest experiences as a creator was meeting her readers in person during an autograph session, where she could directly see their appreciation for her work.
Voice acting
Voice acting
Shimano initially tried balancing the pacing of her lines, but as she read more of the script, she felt that consistently expressing her dialogue energetically would better fit her character. However, she was conscious to do this in a natural way so that Himari would not seem manipulative. She also tried to convey a feeling of initially being more impressed with Yori as compared to being in love with her, which required her to re-record several lines. Seto felt that when Yori first meets Himari, she tries to impress her by putting on a cool persona despite being naturally more excitable. To convey this, Seto deliberately contrasted Yori's calm dialogue with her more flustered internal monologues to show the intensity of Yori's inner thoughts. In addition, Seto always remained aware of Yori's emotional turmoil, even when the script would call for Seto to use an exaggerated tone for her monologues. Yuna Nemoto, who played Shiho, said that she focused on portraying her character's force of will and determination, as well as her negative feelings towards the members of her former band. Due to her character's crucial role in the plot, she received advice from the anime's sound director to deliver her lines in a way that would stir up conflict. To express the intensity of her character's emotions, she projected her voice in a guttural way, which she found exhausting. Mikako Komatsu, who voiced Aki, described her character as someone who experienced love at first sight and has an emotional side. However, because her character tends to also keep things hidden out of consideration for others, Komatsu tried to avoid expressing those feelings too much. She found this balance difficult to maintain, especially in a scene where Aki reacts to Yori's confession to Himari. As the story progressed, she focused on how Aki's feelings became increasingly visible.
Music
Music
Kana Sasakura portrayed Yori's singing voice. She wrote the lyrics for "Orange ni Somatta Oozora" and composed "Okujou no Melody", two of the anime's insert songs. In addition, to convey her character's feelings, she tried to focus on the emotion of her singing rather than just technical skill. For example, after Sasakura recorded multiple takes for "Follow your arrows", the anime's opening song, the director chose a take for the section following the second chorus that he felt carried more nuance and emotion despite being less polished. For the song "Sunny Spot", played in the sixth episode, she revised her approach several times to balance between being expressive and keeping the light mood intended for the song. The same episode also features a scene of SSGIRLS performing, which involved filming motion-capture actors at a live music venue as a basis for the animation. Sui Mizukami portrayed Shiho's singing voice. Mizukami had previously studied at the Berklee College of Music, and was chosen to perform Shiho's songs after the second round of auditions. For the song "Meritocracy", she aimed to convey Shiho's forceful personality, using her natural voice to create an imposing tone. However, she also tried to show Shiho's softer side, and sang certain lines with more hesitance or emotion. Sho Watanabe (composer), the song's composer, helped guide her performance throughout.
Manga
Manga
Written and illustrated by Eku Takeshima, Whisper Me a Love Song began serialization in Japan in the April 2019 issue of Ichijinsha's Comic Yuri Hime magazine. It has been compiled into twelve tankōbon volumes as of May 2026. Kodansha USA licensed the series for English-language release, and has published eleven volumes as of May 2026. Ichijinsha published an anthology of the series titled Whisper Me a Love Song Official Comic Anthology on July 29, 2024. It features standalone stories by various artists that include characters from the series.
Anime
Anime
An anime television series adaptation was announced on January 13, 2023. The series is produced by Cloud Hearts and Yokohama Animation Laboratory. Initially, it was announced that Xinya Cai would direct it; however, Cai stepped down due to health issues, and was replaced by Akira Mano. Hiroki Uchida oversaw the series scripts, Minami Yoshida designed the characters, and Hiroshi Sasaki and Wataru Maeguchi composed the music. The series, initially scheduled to premiere in January 2024 but later delayed, aired the first ten episodes from April 14 to June 30, 2024, on the NUMAnimation programming block on all ANN affiliates, including TV Asahi. The remaining two episodes aired on December 29 of the same year following further production delays. The Blu-ray release, originally slated for four volumes to be released between September 13 and December 13, 2024, was delayed and eventually cancelled due to internal circumstances. The opening theme song is "Follow your arrows", performed by SSGIRLS with vocals by Kana Sasakura. The ending theme song for episodes 2–6 is "Giftee", performed by Hana Shimano, while the ending theme for episode 8 onwards is "Meritocracy", performed by Laureley with vocals by Sui Mizukami. Sentai Filmworks licensed the series for streaming on Hidive.
Stage play
Stage play
In May 2024, it was announced that a stage play adaptation titled Butai: Sasayaku yō ni Koi o Utau would run from the following July 26 to August 2 at the Theater1010 in Tokyo. It is directed by Tomoyuki Ueno and written by Yuniko Ayana, featuring Yui Watanabe (actress) and Momoka Ishii as Himari and Yori respectively.
Accolades and sales
Accolades and sales
In 2020, Whisper Me a Love Song was nominated for Niconico and Da Vincis Next Manga Awards, ranking eighteenth out of fifty nominees, and won Yuri Navis Yuri Manga Awards, placing first out of 196 nominees. In the same year, it placed second in Yuri Navis general poll and went on to claim first place in 2021. By March 2024, the series had sold over 500,000 copies. By August 2024, the series had sold over one million copies. In a 2025 poll of users' favorite yuri anime hosted by the site Anime! Anime!, the show placed sixth.
Manga
Manga
The manga's story was well received. Anson Leung of Broken Frontier acclaimed its central romance, writing that the series "hooks you with its realism, its sincerity, its warmth, its humor, and its unconditional acceptance of queer love." Sara Smith of The Graphic Library described the first volume as "very cute" and "sweet love story", scoring it 8/10 overall, while Erica Friedman of Okazu, reviewing the second volume, called it "an oasis of innocence and joy" and a "genuine delight", rating it an 8/10 as well. Several critics praised the series' characters, with Rebecca Silverman of Anime News Network (ANN) opining that their imperfections made them "all so human" and commending how they were "unabashedly themselves". Similarly, Friedman described the characters as "relatable [and] charming", scoring that aspect of the story a 9/10. Leung commented favorably on Himari's character, describing her journey of self-discovery as showing a "level of emotional maturity" that "speak[s] volumes to any reader". The series' themes of LGBTQ+ representation were met with favorable reactions. Leung noted that Himari and Yori's lesbian relationship is treated normally by other characters, which he felt allowed the story to avoid "heteronormative prejudice" and become a "truly exceptional queer love story". Likewise, Friedman praised a scene where Himari's mother fully accepts Himari having a girlfriend, calling "nice to see" compared to the typical "fraught" scenes of the genre. Silverman commended the story's depiction of "love just being love", later suggesting that Himari's portrayal left the possibility of her being demisexual and demiromantic. Regarding the art style, Friedman praised Takeshima's illustrations, stating that it had a "dramatic quality" that was "very appealing". On the other hand, Silverman felt that the art was sometimes overly toned and gave it a B+ rating. Meanwhile, Leung opined that the art was deliberately stylized in a way that added elements of "fluffiness" and "warmth" to the story.
Anime
Anime
The anime's premiere was generally well received. Nicholas Dupree of ANN praised the premise, calling it "charming, sweet, and funny in equal measure", while James Beckett of the same site described it as "simple and sugary-sweet in all the right ways" and a "pleasure to watch". Chris Beveridge of Fandom Post characterized the debut episode as "very appealing and easy to stick with" for the strength of its story, giving it a B+ rating overall. The anime's plot and characters were praised by several critics. Beveridge commented favorably on Himari and Yori's relationship, stating that it was "executed pretty well" and had "some real stakes". Vrai Kaiser of Anime Feminist likewise spoke positively of their relationship, opining that the series had a "surprising amount of introspection". Silverman commended the "strength of the romance" but was hesitant regarding pacing, feeling that the way that scenes transitioned broke up the story's flow. Early reviews of the anime's production value were generally positive; Kaiser opined that it "looks soft and romantic in all the right moments". However, the production value of the anime's later episodes was criticized by many reviewers, with Kaiser stating that the "visuals really begin to struggle" there. Similarly, Silverman contended that production issues in the eight episode created some "truly awkward art" and bland illustrations. Josh Piedra of The Outerhaven said that sometimes the "art just suffered", with background patterns being "out of place and quite jarring". The music received mixed comments. Piedra described it as "pretty good" but criticized the lack of full songs, while Richard Eisenbeis of ANN felt that it was not compelling enough despite being "above average". Kaiser called the anime's soundtrack "pleasant but unremarkable" with the exception of the song "Meritocracy", which she praised as having a "compelling bite". Silverman opined that in the final episode, the show "finally delivers the music that was lacking from its earlier outings". Overall reviews following the anime's conclusion were also mixed. Friedman contended that the anime had "mauled" the manga with its poor production and regretted its wasted potential. Meanwhile, Kaiser acknowledged that the anime was "decidedly rough around the edges", but recommended it anyway, stating it was "very sweet" and had compelling drama. Silverman concluded that it "never fully lives up to its promise", but was still "glad that [she] watched this".
Places
Named by the record
Places
Only places the record itself states, plotted where the house gazetteer settles their coordinates. Nothing is inferred from a name or a nationality.
- Japan
Recording
For the adaptation, several changes to the story's presentation were made. For example, the scene where Himari confesses her love for Yori's singing was shown from both their perspectives in the original manga, but for the anime, this was condensed into a single scene from only Yori's perspective, shifting its emotional atmosphere. The anime's voice actors were chosen through a tape audition, where they would read a script and send in a recording. Takeshima participated in the selection process, and after listening to around 60 recordings, she suggested that Hana Shimano voice Himari. Together with the anime's director, she also recommended that Asami Seto play Yori. The recording took place in an atmosphere that the voice actors described as welcoming, and they gave advice to each other on how to best deliver lines. The sound director guided the voice actors on their performances. In addition, the voice actors frequently improvised dialogue.
Notes from the source article
Cited by Wikipedia
Notes from the source article
These works are cited by the source article, in its own numbering. They are recorded as its citations, not as sources VALÉORINE has verified.
- 1.Kodansha Comics. Whisper Me a Love Song, Volume 1.
- 2.Une pièce de théâtre adaptée du manga Whispering You a Love Song annoncée pour cet été au Japon. Anime News Network. February 28, 2025.
- 3.Luster, Joseph. Whisper Me a Love Song Anime Reveals Singers for Band Performances. Crunchyroll News.
- 4.Whisper Me a Love Song. Behind The Voice Actors.
- 5.ja:君に好きっていわせたい(最新刊). I Want You to Say I Love You (latest volume). live.
- 6.Yuri Navi. August 17, 2020.
- 7.Animate Times. March 21, 2024.
- 8.Animate Times. April 17, 2024.
- 9.Pash! Plus. May 1, 2024.
- 10.Pash! Plus. April 24, 2024.
- 11.Pash! Plus. June 5, 2024.
- 12.Pash! Plus. May 22, 2024.
- 13.Animate Times. June 26, 2024.
- 14.Ichijinsha.
- 15.Ichijinsha.
- 16.Mateo, Alex. Kodansha Comics Announces 12 Digital Manga Licenses, 4 Manga Print Releases. Anime News Network. November 17, 2019.
- 17.Kodansha Comics. Whisper Me a Love Song, Volume 11. Kodansha.
- 18.Ichijinsha.
- 19.Nwaenie, Chike. Whisper Me a Love Song Anime Reveals Delay, First Trailer and New Director. Anime Corner. November 10, 2023.
- 20.Hodgkins, Crystalyn. Eku Takeshima's Whisper Me a Love Song Manga Gets TV Anime. Anime News Network. January 13, 2023.
- 21.Hodgkins, Crystalyn. Whisper Me a Love Song TV Anime Reveals Teaser Visual, More Cast, January 2024 Premiere. Anime News Network. March 17, 2023.
- 22.Loo, Egan. Whisper Me a Love Song Yuri Anime's 1st Full Promo Video Announces New Director, More Staff, April Delay. Anime News Network. November 10, 2023.
- 23.Hodgkins, Crystalyn. Whisper Me a Love Song Yuri Anime Reveals More Cast. Anime News Network. February 2, 2024.
- 24.Hodgkins, Crystalyn. Whisper Me a Love Song Anime's Episodes 11, 12 to Air on December 28. Anime News Network. November 14, 2024.
- 25.Pineda, Rafael Antonio. Whisper Me a Love Song Studio Cloud Hearts' Domain Name Expires. Anime News Network. October 24, 2024.
- 26.Tai, Anita. Whisper Me a Love Song Anime's Japanese Blu-ray Disc Release Canceled. Anime News Network. January 7, 2025.
- 27.Hazra, Adriana. Whisper Me a Love Song Yuri Anime Reveals April 13 Debut, Key Visual, Theme Songs. Anime News Network. March 8, 2024.
- 28.1796950071994720594. June 1, 2024.
- 29.Tai, Anita. HIDIVE Adds Whisper Me a Love Song Anime to Spring Line-Up. Anime News Network. March 13, 2024.
- 30.Cayanan, Joanna. Eku Takeshima's Whisper Me a Love Song Manga Gets Stage Play Adaptation. Anime News Network. May 5, 2024.
- 31.Loveridge, Lynzee. Shonen Jump's Undead Unluck Wins Tsugi ni Kuru Manga 2020 Awards. Anime News Network. August 19, 2020.
- 32.eeo Media. March 29, 2023.
- 33.Yuri Navi.
- 34.Mangapedia.
- 35.Animate Times. March 8, 2024.
- 36.Oricon News. August 29, 2024.
- 37.Cho! Animedia. August 3, 2025.
- 38.Leung, Anson. Whisper Me a Love Song Vol. 1–4 – Eku Takeshima's Realistically Paced Queer Love Story is a Heartwarming Tale. Broken Frontier. June 30, 2022.
- 39.Smith, Sara. Book review: Whisper Me a Love Song vol 1 by Eku Takeshima. The Graphic Library. January 16, 2024.
- 40.Friedman, Erica. Okazu » Whisper Me a Love Song, Volume 2. Okazu. October 18, 2021.
- 41.Silverman, Rebecca. Whisper Me a Love Song GN 1–3 – Review. Anime News Network. August 8, 2021.
- 42.Friedman, Erica. Okazu » Sasayakuyouni Koi wo Utau, Volume 10 (ささやくように恋を唄う). Okazu. January 9, 2025.
- 43.The Most Anticipated Anime of Spring 2024. Anime News Network. March 27, 2024.
- 44.Friedman, Erica. Okazu » Sasayakuyouni Koi wo Utau, Volume 2 (ささやくように恋を唄う). Okazu. July 16, 2020.
- 45.Kaiser, Vrai. Whisper Me a Love Song – Episode 1. Anime Feminist. April 15, 2024.
- 46.The Spring 2024 Anime Preview Guide – Whisper Me a Love Song. Anime News Network. April 13, 2024.
- 47.Friedman, Erica. Okazu » Whisper Me A Love Song Anime. Okazu. April 15, 2024.
- 48.Beveridge, Chris. Whisper Me A Love Song Episode #01 Anime Review. Fandom Post. April 16, 2024.
- 49.2024 Spring Three-Episode Check-In. Anime Feminist. May 3, 2024.
- 50.Silverman, Rebecca. Whisper Me a Love Song ‒ SEASON PREMIERE. Anime News Network. April 21, 2024.
- 51.Friedman, Erica. Okazu » Sasayakuyouni Koi wo Utau, Volume 8 (ささやくように恋を唄う). Okazu. September 26, 2024.
- 52.Anime Feminist Recommendations of Fall 2024. Anime Feminist. January 17, 2025.
- 53.Silverman, Rebecca. Whisper Me a Love Song ‒ Episode 8. Anime News Network. June 3, 2024.
- 54.Piedra, Josh. Anime Review: Sasayaku You ni Koi wo Utau. The Outerhaven. January 1, 2025.
- 55.Silverman, Rebecca. Whisper Me a Love Song ‒ SERIES FINALE. Anime News Network. December 30, 2024.
References
Citations
References
Each reference names the institution holding it, so a reader may go to the document itself.
reference work
Secondary witnessreference work
Secondary witness
The Encyclopedia exists whether or not anything is for sale. Corrections are recorded rather than overwritten, and every version of this record is kept. Published 14 August 2026.
Elsewhere in Comics and comic art
9,920 published records in this field, each with its sources named.
- When a Cat Faces WestSeries
- When the Wind BlowsSeries
- When Will Ayumu Make His Move?Series
- Whilce PortacioArtist
- Whispered WordsSeries
- Whistle!Series
- Whit TaylorArtist
- White BrandSeries
Best supported in this field
For owners
Own a copy of Whisper Me a Love Song?
A specialist will read what you send and tell you what the house can establish, what it cannot, and whether the object is suited to sale. There is no charge and no obligation. The object stays with you throughout; nothing is shipped to us unless it is arranged in writing beforehand.