Max Strub

Appointed Germany's youngest music professor at the Hochschule für Musik Franz Liszt, Weimar in 1926, he followed calls to the Berlin University of the Arts and, after the Second World War to the Hochschule für Musik Detmold. Strub was a connoisseur of the classical-romantic repertoire, but also devoted himself to modern music, among others he gave the world premiere of Hindemith's Violin Sonata No. 2 in D major. He promoted the music of Hans Pfitzner. Strub played on a Stradivari violin until 1945; numerous recordings from the 1930s/40s document his work.

Strub was born in 1900 as the eldest of three children of the photographer Otto Strub and his wife Ida, née Göhringer, in Mainz in the then Grand Duchy of Hesse-Darmstadt. His mother was the daughter of a cigarette manufacturer from the neighboring Biebrich, a district of Wiesbaden that was later incorporated. His sister Elisabeth married an American manufacturer with whom she was to settle in Weimar. Rosa, his younger sister, also spent most of her life there. The father earned his living mainly with post-mortem photography. In his Mainz atelier in the Frauenlobstraße 25 in Neustadt, European violinists such as Willy Burmester, Joseph Joachim, Jan Kubelík and Henri Marteau as well as the still young Franz von Vecsey, whom he in turn photographed for free. Otto Strub was himself a passionate amateur violinist and supported Max musically to the best of his ability. There was a piano in his studio and he received his first piano lessons at the age of five. From the age of six he was taught violin by Alfred Stauffer, concertmaster of the Philharmonisches Staatsorchester Mainz. Kubelik recommended the ambitious father to contact the Viennese violin professor Otakar Ševčík. In his correspondence, however, he advised against a career as a musician for financial reasons. In his native town, Strub attended the Rabanus-Maurus-Gymnasium, where he showed himself to be musically and artistically talented. He played in the school orchestra there, whose first violin he soon took over. The writer Carl Zuckmayer, four years his senior, with whom he was friends throughout his life, belonged to the cello group, Strub gave his first public concert at the age of twelve. He played with the Mainz orchestra Max Bruch's Violin Concerto No. 1 in G minor. Two years later, he performed Beethoven's Violin Concerto and the 3rd Piano Concerto in Frankfurt (then in Hessen-Nassau), among others. Zuckmayer retrospectively described the young Strub as a musical "child prodigy".

Strub, who was gifted for playing piano and violin, had to make a decision and – without Abitur – sixteen years old on the advice of the conductor Fritz Busch, brother of the violinist Adolf Busch, the decision to join the violin class of the former concertmaster of the Berlin Philharmonic at the Rheinische Musikschule. Bram Eldering, a pupil of Joseph Joachim, to enter. Besides Strub, Adolf Busch and Wilhelm Stross were also trained by the Dutch music teacher Eldering. Together with his mother and younger sister, the underage student Strub lived with a landlord during the First World War. He was able to play until 1918 as second violinist at the orchestra rehearsals of the municipal Gürzenich Orchestra Cologne under the musical direction of Hermann Abendroth. He was open to all styles, including contemporary music. In 1918, Strub was awarded the Mendelssohn Prize in Berlin, combined with a performance under the conductor Otto Klemperer that was well-received in the local press. Together with the growing cello virtuoso Emanuel Feuermann he played Brahms' Double Concerto in A minor. He remained at the Cologne Conservatory for another year.

After a tour of Germany and Italy, in August 1921 the Landes music director Fritz Busch brought Strub to Stuttgart as concert master and thus successor to Karl Wendling at the orchestra of the Staatstheater Stuttgart. Strub, who had little orchestral experience at the time, was Busch's last choice after the application process had been disillusioned. Busch described him as a "first-rate violinist" and predicted a steep career for him. His contract obliged him to perform opera and symphony concerts, i.e. 10 performances plus rehearsals each, whereby he was released from rehearsals and from the operetta service. At the events in the opera, the concertmaster Reinhold Rohlfs-Zoll, who had been Wendling's representative for a time, was treated as an equal. Busch pursued a modern programming at the Landestheaterorchester, which was not always received positively by the critics. During Strub's period of service, in October 1921, Ewald Straesser's Fourth Symphony op. 44 premiered in the Stuttgart Kultur- und Kongresszentrum Liederhalle. The private citizen Strub became acquainted with the Busch family of musicians and the conductor Busch later became godfather of his son Harald Strub, along with the violin teacher Eldering.

With Busch, who had been enticed away to Dresden, Strub moved to the Sächsische Staatskapelle Dresden of the Staatsoper Dresden (Semperoper) in 1922, where he took the position of first concertmaster. After his performance of Brahms' Violin concerto the orchestra decided unanimously for Strub. During his time with the orchestra in 1924 at the Staatsschauspiel Dresden, Busch was responsible for the premiere of Strauss’ Intermezzo, "bürgerlichen Komödie mit sinfonischen Zwischenspielen" (bourgeois comedy with symphonic interludes). In the same year, Strub was assigned the Dutch violinist Jan Dahmen as first concert master. After Strub had left the Saxon capital in favour of a career as a soloist and music teacher, he was succeeded by Karl Thomann. In 1923, Strub replaced Gustav Havemann as first violinist in the Petri Quartet, to which the orchestra musicians Erdmann Warwas (2nd violin), Alfred Spitzner (alto) and Georg Wille (violoncello) belonged. According to the historian Michael Hans Kater, he soon surpassed his predecessor Havemann as a string player.

A friend of the family of his wife Hilde Neuffer, who was married in 1922, the director of the music school Bruno Hinze-Reinhold, moved the Strubs to Thuringia the state capital of Weimar. From April 1925, Strub was the full-time head of one of the two violin classes (alongside Robert Reitz) at the Hochschule für Musik Franz Liszt, Weimar as successor to the pedagogue Paul Elgers. He established the violin school Die Kunst des Violinspiels (1923) in Weimar of the internationally active violin teacher Carl Flesch known to him. In 1926, 26-year-old Strub was the youngest musician in Germany to receive a professorship. According to the Weimar composer and music teacher Eduard August Molnar jr., his vocation, however, also brought forth envious people who only approved of such a teaching obligation around the age of 60. To avert Strub's departure for Berlin, he was made a civil servant in 1927; in addition, his salary increased. Although Strub moved to the capital in 1928, he continued to teach in Weimar two days a week until 1930. Also because of its international reputation, the music school was transformed into a music academy in 1930. In the 1927/28 season, he briefly represented the conductor Ernst Praetorius at the music school orchestra that was being established. In 1927, following in the footsteps of Robert Reitz, he formed together with Bruno Hinze-Reinhold (pianist) and Walter Schulz (cellist) the Weimarer Trio. His successor was Hans Bassermann in 1930. During the Weimar years he occasionally played in a duo with his wife Hilde. The couple lived in a rented apartment near the Schloss Weimar.

• Illustration — State Opera on Republic Square (Kroll-Oper) in Berlin (1930) Generalmusikdirektor Otto Klemperer engaged Strub in 1928 with the Austrian Josef Wolfsthal as co-concert master at the Staatskapelle Berlin, whereby Strub was assigned to the Kroll section, i.e. the venue of the Staatsoper am Platz der Republik. The programme included classical-romantic works as well as new symphonies by contemporary composers such as Max Butting and Ernst Krenek. In his apartment on the Lützowufer (Landwehr Canal) in 1931, Strub, who at the time was separated from his wife Hilde, accommodated the American composer Aaron Copland as well as Barbara and Roger Sessions. The originally planned Violin Concerto by Sessions did not come true due to a nervous breakdown by Strub. Even with the new soloist Albert Spalding, the composer could not come to an agreement in the end, so that the delayed work would not be performed for the first time in the USA until the 1940s. Public pressure from conservative cultural policy circles in Berlin and the economic consequences of the Great Depression led to the closure of the progressive house in 1931. Despite the decision of the Prussian policy, Strub remained loyal to the Staatskapelle and became successor of the young deceased Wolfsthal in 1931.

After the Machtergreifung by the Nazis in 1933, Strub was one of the musicians who remained in the German Reich. After the engagement of the second concertmaster of the Berlin Philharmonic Orchestra (BPO), Wilfried Hanke, to the Hamburg State Theatre, Wilhelm Furtwängler invited him as guest concertmaster on the foreign tour of his orchestra to England. The BPO appeared in January 1934 with a classical-romantic programme among others in the London Queen's Hall and the Royal Albert Hall. Strub made his solo debut in 1937 with Brahms' violin concerto at the BPO under the musical direction of the Swiss conductor Robert F. Denzler. Among the numerous solo concerts Strub gave during the National Socialist period, were cultural events of decidedly political organizations such as the Militant League for German Culture and the staff music corps of the SS-Hauptämter. In 1943, he also took part in a Zwickau memorial concert for the "Gefallenen der Bewegung". In 1935, Strub founded a piano trio with Friedrich Wührer (piano) and Paul Grümmer (cello). During the 1935 Summer, he succeeded the US-American violin virtuoso Florizel von Reuter in the piano trio of the pianist Elly Ney and the cellist Ludwig Hoelscher, with whom he played until 1940. Recordings of works by Schubert, Beethoven, Brahms and Schumann were made. Although the Ney Trio had its origins in the Weimar Republic, their leader Ney was close to the NS regime. Unlike Hoelscher, however, Strub could hardly be described as opportunistic. Thus, unlike his colleagues, he did not become a party member. Strub formed another trio in 1943 with the Swiss pianist Adrian Aeschbacher and the Spanish cellist Gaspar Cassadó. They continued to produce recordings after the war. In addition, Strub repeatedly performed chamber music with the pianist and Pfitzner's friend Walter Gieseking. In 1940, they gave a concert in Hannover as part of a concert of the Nazi community "Kraft durch Freude". The programme included works by Schubert, Beethoven and Pfitzner. He also persuaded his students Hans-Ulrich Tiesler, Max Kayser and Franz Hopfner to perform the world premiere of Gieseking's Kleine Musik for three violins, which took place in the theatre hall of the Berlin University of the Arts. At the same conservatory he represented Carl Flesch in the summer of 1933/34, who had a special agreement with the university since 1928. In July 1933 Strub was appointed a professor. In 1934, due to his Berlin commitments, he declined a call to the Hochschule für Musik und Theater München, where he was to take over the direction of a master class. In the post-war period in Germany, he did not return to the West Berlin Academy of Music, despite a hiring order. In 1944 Strub was included in the Gottbegnadeten list ("Führerliste") as one of the most important violinists in the Third Reich, which saved him from military service.

After the Second World War, Strub was temporarily accepted in Wels in Upper Austria by the composer friend Johann Nepomuk David. The Mozarteum Orchestra Salzburg then engaged him for three years as concertmaster. At the Salzburg Festival in 1946 he performed Bruckner's Mass No. 3 with the orchestra conducted by Joseph Messner. In 1947 he was a teacher at the Internationale Sommerakademie Mozarteum Salzburg.

For the 1947/48 winter semester, Strub took over the master classes for violin, interpretation and chamber music at the Hochschule für Musik Detmold; In 1957 he received a professorship. He often played as a soloist with the Nordwestdeutsche Philharmonie in Herford under the direction of Rolf Agop. In the 1950s, Strub founded a piano trio with the pianist Hans Richter-Haaser and the cellist Hans Münch-Holland. During the Cold War he was repeatedly (1964–1966) invited as guest professor to the International Music Seminar of the GDR at the Hochschule für Musik "Franz Liszt" Weimar, his former workplace. Like before in Leipzig, when Hermann Abendroth was still kapellmeister at the Gewandhaus, he also frequented the conductor's house in Weimar, whom he already knew from his Cologne years. He also gave concerts with him, about 1949 as soloist at a concert of the Staatskapelle Weimar in Jena. Strub last lived in Detmold and Stuttgart. After a stroke in 1966, Strub died at the age of 65 years in the hospital Bad Oeynhausen in Regierungsbezirk Detmold.

During his time in Berlin, Strub met the Swiss pianist Edwin Fischer, who accepted him into his chamber orchestra specialising in historically informed performance, supported him as a duo partner and encouraged him to form a string quartet. In 1929, together with Josef Krips, Rudolf Nel and Hans Schrader, he founded the first Strub Quartet. Four further instrumentations were to follow until 1965, among them the one that emerged in 1935 from the "Bonn Beethoven Quartet" with Jost Raba, Walter Trampler and Ludwig Hoelscher. The ensemble was one of the most famous German string quartets, played at home and abroad and was allowed to take over almost half of the Gewandhaus chamber concerts in Leipzig from the end of the 1930s.

Shortly before the end of the Second World War, Strub worked in the County of Glatz in the Province of Silesia. With the approach of the Red Army, he, like other members of the Philharmonic, began to flee in a westward direction. In Prague he was briefly arrested by the Gestapo and after his release he was taken prisoner by Czech and Russian troops. In May 1945 he was sent to the infamous Strahov Stadium Ilag. There, he was brought before a military court as a supposed high party functionary, but was able to prove his musical profession by an audition. His Stradivari violin (1716), which he carried with him in a double case next to the Grancino, was irrevocably stolen by Russian soldiers. The valuable instrument was originally given to him by the Frankfurt patron Wilhelm Merton as permanent loan.

• Illustration — Johann Sebastian Bach's Violin Concerto in A minor, BWV 1041, Max Strub and the Berliner Instrumental-Collegium conducted by Fritz Stein (1939) Strub was a highly regarded interpreter of the "three big Bs" (Bach, Beethoven and Brahms). Thus he appeared as a soloist and others at the 25th German Bachfest of the Neue Bachgesellschaft in Leipzig, where he performed Bachs's sonata in A minor. A guest concert took the soloist Strub to the Lorensbergsteatern in Gothenburg in 1931, where he performed with the Gothenburg Symphony Orchestra conducted by Paul Scheinpflug. Under the conduct of Karl Böhm, Strub played two Brahms and Pfitzner concerts with the Vienna Symphony in the Konzerthaus, Vienna in 1938. He performed several times in the 1930s, 40s and 50s under the musical direction of Joseph Keilberth. He also recorded pieces for the Reichssender, whereby no decidedly "political music" was interpreted. He had repeated appearances in the 1930s and 40s at the Beethovenfest and the chamber music festival in Bonn. His engagement for Ludwig van Beethoven went so far that in 1938 he participated with Hoelscher and Ney in the Beethoven-Fest of the Hitlerjugend in Bad Wildbad in the Black Forest and heroized the composer there. The guiding principles were printed in the Neue Zeitschrift für Musik. In the 1942/43 season, a guest performance took him to the Leipzig Gewandhaus, where he performed Beethoven's Violin concerto. After a complete cycle of all Beethoven string quartets at the Conservatorio Giuseppe Verdi in Milan, in 1942 Strub became the fifth violinist ever – after Adolf Busch, Lucien Capet, Eugène Ysaÿe and Joseph Joachim – honorary member of the Società del Quartetto di Milano. Außerdem erhielt er ein Diplom als Ehrenmitglied des Bonner Beethoven-Hauses und ein Bild seines Streichquartetts wurde ebendort ausgestellt. In 1952, he attended a reception in Bonn with the Federal President Theodor Heuss and the Federal Chancellor Konrad Adenauer as well as the musicians Elly Ney and Wilhelm Backhaus in the context of the Beethoven celebration.

Strub was one of the first German violinists to perform modern solo concertos and duos such as Alexander Glazunov's Violin Concerto (1923), Béla Bartók's 1st Sonata for violin and piano (1924), Darius Milhaud's Sonata for two violins (with Joseph Gustav Mraczek; 1925) and Karol Szymanowski's Violin Concerto No. 1 (1929) which he included in his repertoire. In 1922 he took part in the Concert performance as violinist and viola player at the Cologne first performance of Arnold Schoenberg's melodrama Pierrot Lunaire. In 1931 he participated in a performance of Bohuslav Martinůs Piano Trio No. 1 (Cinq pièces brèves) in Berlin, which was organized by the Berlin chapter of the International Society for Contemporary Music. Through his participation in 1938 and 1939 to the National Socialist Propaganda Reichsmusiktage in Düsseldorf, he allowed himself to be politically instrumentalized as an artist. During the first Reichsmusiktage he took over the soloist part in the Second Symphony Concert. The Düsseldorfer Symphoniker played the violin concerto Geigenmusik in drei Sätzen (1936). under the direction of Hugo Balzer. The atonal work of the Berlin composer Boris Blacher was considered controversial at the time. Contemporary composers like Günter Bialas, Karl Bleyle, Hans Pfitzner and Lothar Windsperger dedicated pieces to him. The premiere of the Violin Concerto op. 46 by Reinhard Schwarz-Schilling, which was scheduled as the 6th symphony concert of the Philharmonic Society of Bremen for 6 January 1941 with Strub as soloist and the Bremer Philharmoniker conducted by Hellmut Schnackenburg, was withdrawn at short notice by the composer. After a revision in 1953, the premiere finally took place in 1954 without Strub. World premieres as soloist and chamber musician • Composer — Work — Event — Location — Year — Other performers • Paul Hindemith — Sonata in D for piano and violin, Op. 11, No. 2 — Frankfurt — 1920 — Eduard Zuckmayer • Lothar Windsperger — Violin Concerto, Op. 39 — Essen — 1927 — Düsseldorfer Symphoniker conducted by Hans Weisbach • Lothar Windsperger — String Quartet — Koblenz — 1933 — B. Marusat (?), R. Neb (?) and Hans Schrader (Strub Quartet) • Hans Pfitzner — Duo for violin and violoncello with small orchestra, Op. 43 — Frankfurter Museumsgesellschaft — Frankfurt — 1937 — Ludwig Hoelscher and the municipal orchestra (Frankfurter Opern- und Museumsorchester) under the direction of the composer • Karl Höller — String Quartet in E major, Op. 24 — Gewandhaus chamber music — Leipzig — 1938 — Jost Raba, Walter Trampler and Ludwig Hoelscher (Strub Quartet) • Johann Nepomuk David — Duo concertante for violin and cello, Werk 19 — 2nd Gewandhaus chamber music — Leipzig — 1938 — Ludwig Hoelscher • Paul Juon — Burletta for violin and orchestra. Werk 97 — 4th Symphony concert — Dresden — 1940 — Sächsische Staatskapelle Dresden conducted by Peter Raabe • Anton Bruckner / Armin Knab (editor) — String Quintet (arr, of the trio sketches in F major and F sharp major to the Scherzo of the Symphony No. 9 in D minor (WAB 109) — 2nd Leipziger Bruckner-Fest — Leipzig — 1940 — Hermann Hubl, Hermann Hirschfelder and Hans Münch-Holland (Strub Quartet) as well as Emil Seiler • Theodor Berger — Rhapsodic Duo for violin and cello with Orchestra, Op. 9 — Frankfurt — 1942 — Rudolf Metzmacher • Hans Pfitzner — String Quartet in C minor, Op. 50 — Berlin Art Weeks — Berlin — 1942 — Hermann Hubl, Hermann Hirschfelder and Hans Münch-Holland (Strub Quartet) • Johannes Driessler — String Quartet, Op. 41/1 — Ten-year anniversary of the Hochschule für Musik Detmold — Detmold — 1957 — Ruth Wagner, Walter Müller and Irene Güdel (Strub Quartet) • Günter Bialas — String Trio — musica-viva-Konzert / 50th birthday of the composer — Detmold — 1957 — Walter Müller and Irene Güdel

Strub, who came into contact with the works of Hans Pfitzner as a seventeen-year-old, became acquainted with the composer in the 1920s at the Stuttgart Opera. He became friend with him and from then on promoted his music. Strub war selbst dedicator of Pfitzner's Duo für Violine, Violoncello und kleines Orchester op. 43 und von dessen Streichquartett op. 50. The Ney-Trio played especially the piano trio in F major op. 8 by Pfitzner. As a soloist Strub performed Pfitzner's violin concerto with the BPO under Hans Knappertsbusch (in the Berlin Philharmonic) and Joseph Keilberth (in the Admiralspalast). The latter should have been his last concert before the end of the Second World War. Immediately before Pfitzner's death (1949), Strub visited his friend in Salzburg, where a series of photographs was taken. The year before his death, Strub was elected Deputy Chairman of the Hans Pfitzner Society in Munich. The music historian Fred K. Prieberg quoted Strub in the Handbuch Deutsche Musiker 1933–1945 among others with the following words referring to Pfitzner, which Strub found in a publication about the Kulturpolitisches Arbeitslager of the Kultur- und Rundfunkamt der Reichsjugendführer 1938: The harmonious triad: creator, reproducer and receptive, as Pfitzner says, here in the concerts for the Hitler Youth, there is a reverent note, and a fundamental tone forms the basis on which the guardians of German art should grow up!

From 1922 to 1932, Strub was married to his former fellow student Hilde Neuffer (1897–1980; later Rawson). She came from a Weimar family of artists and was the daughter of the Jewish court actor Dagobert Neuffer and the writer Hildegard Neuffer-Stavenhagen. The Strubs married in the Evangelical-Lutheran Herderkirche in Weimar and had two children. Their son Harald Strub (1923–1988) became a cellist and member of the Arriaga Quartet. Their daughter Elgin Strub (Ronayne), born in 1929, a concert pianist and author of various articles on the Strub Neuffer-Stavenhagen family history, including 'Skizzen einer Künstlerfamilie in Weimar', which is the basis of much of this article. His Irish son-in-law John Ronayne was among others concertmaster of the Bavarian Radio Symphony Orchestra. In 1938 Strub married the Italian pianist Maria-Luisa Moresco; their son Patrick Strub (born 1947) became a conductor and violinist.

The character of the famous cellist Felix in the film comedy All These Women (1964) by the Swedish director Ingmar Bergman is loosely based on the German violinist Jonathan Vogler, a pseudonym for Strub.

Strub's correspondence with personalities of his time is distributed among various archives and libraries such as the Saxon State and University Library Dresden, the Landesbibliothek Coburg, the Universitätsbibliothek Würzburg, the Bavarian State Library in Munich and the Deutsches Literaturarchiv Marbach.

• Ernst Laaff: Vom Anfangsunterricht und vom Konzertsolisten. Gespräch mit Max Strub. In Das Musikleben 1 (1948) 2, p. 50f.

Max Strub is recorded with the occupation university teacher. Recorded with the occupation concertmaster. Recorded with the occupation violinist. Recorded with the occupation musician. Recorded as concertmaster, university teacher, violinist and musician.