{"note":"Chain of a reading: claim, supporting assertions, locator inside the read source, snapshot metadata. Snapshot bodies are never served.","slug":"john-duncan","claims":[{"value":{"text":"Dundee"},"support":[{"role":"SUBJECT","value":{"text":"Dundee","authority_id":"http://vocab.getty.edu/tgn/7009741"},"locator":{"verbatim":"Dundee","field_path":"$.born.took_place_at[0]._label","locator_id":428468},"snapshot":{"revision":"","access_url":"https://vocab.getty.edu/ulan/500000149.json","http_status":200,"snapshot_id":64020,"source_work":"getty:500000149","content_hash":"f3efe07c8d2db74e9d54f113ead1afce337b8608e0af92907f547c9b3d9ec3d8","retrieved_at":"2026-09-30T09:12:05.965391+00:00","licence_basis":"ODC-By 1.0 (Open Data Commons Attribution) — Getty Vocabularies, Union List of Artist Names, vocab.getty.edu","reader_version":"rdoc-multi-2.2.0"},"precision":"NOT_APPLICABLE","predicate":"birth_place","depends_on":null,"event_type":"BIRTH","quantifier":"SINGLE","attribution":"J. Paul Getty Trust, Getty Vocabulary Program — Union List of Artist Names (ULAN)®","source_work":"getty:500000149","uncertainty":null,"assertion_id":296140,"source_family":"ULAN","subject_scope":"entity:29b71f8f-d0e7-44a3-aa2d-74d201f6744d"}],"claim_id":170433,"precision":"NOT_APPLICABLE","predicate":"birth_place","admitted_at":"2026-09-30T09:12:05.965391+00:00","decision_id":237425},{"value":{"text":"1866","year":1866,"precision":"YEAR"},"support":[{"role":"SUBJECT","value":{"text":"1866","year":1866,"precision":"YEAR"},"locator":{"verbatim":"1866","field_path":"548[0]$a[0]","locator_id":451980},"snapshot":{"revision":"20080717110957.0","access_url":"https://d-nb.info/gnd/11927907X/about/marcxml","http_status":200,"snapshot_id":67329,"source_work":"gnd:11927907X","content_hash":"533b7c5c83fd298b507501659e6459054da4f81ad329f5aab10407ed9ce513e3","retrieved_at":"2026-09-30T13:53:29.018935+00:00","licence_basis":"CC0 1.0 (Deutsche Nationalbibliothek, Gemeinsame Normdatei, d-nb.info)","reader_version":"rdoc-multi-2.2.0"},"precision":"YEAR","predicate":"born","depends_on":null,"event_type":"BIRTH","quantifier":"SINGLE","attribution":"Deutsche Nationalbibliothek, Gemeinsame Normdatei","source_work":"gnd:11927907X","uncertainty":null,"assertion_id":311845,"source_family":"DNB-GND","subject_scope":"entity:29b71f8f-d0e7-44a3-aa2d-74d201f6744d"},{"role":"SUBJECT","value":{"text":"1866","year":1866,"precision":"YEAR"},"locator":{"verbatim":"1866","field_path":"$.born.timespan","locator_id":428467},"snapshot":{"revision":"","access_url":"https://vocab.getty.edu/ulan/500000149.json","http_status":200,"snapshot_id":64020,"source_work":"getty:500000149","content_hash":"f3efe07c8d2db74e9d54f113ead1afce337b8608e0af92907f547c9b3d9ec3d8","retrieved_at":"2026-09-30T09:12:05.965391+00:00","licence_basis":"ODC-By 1.0 (Open Data Commons Attribution) — Getty Vocabularies, Union List of Artist Names, vocab.getty.edu","reader_version":"rdoc-multi-2.2.0"},"precision":"YEAR","predicate":"born","depends_on":null,"event_type":"BIRTH","quantifier":"SINGLE","attribution":"J. Paul Getty Trust, Getty Vocabulary Program — Union List of Artist Names (ULAN)®","source_work":"getty:500000149","uncertainty":null,"assertion_id":296139,"source_family":"ULAN","subject_scope":"entity:29b71f8f-d0e7-44a3-aa2d-74d201f6744d"}],"claim_id":170432,"precision":"YEAR","predicate":"born","admitted_at":"2026-09-30T09:12:05.965391+00:00","decision_id":237424},{"value":{"text":"Edinburgh"},"support":[{"role":"SUBJECT","value":{"text":"Edinburgh","authority_id":"http://vocab.getty.edu/tgn/7009546"},"locator":{"verbatim":"Edinburgh","field_path":"$.died.took_place_at[0]._label","locator_id":428470},"snapshot":{"revision":"","access_url":"https://vocab.getty.edu/ulan/500000149.json","http_status":200,"snapshot_id":64020,"source_work":"getty:500000149","content_hash":"f3efe07c8d2db74e9d54f113ead1afce337b8608e0af92907f547c9b3d9ec3d8","retrieved_at":"2026-09-30T09:12:05.965391+00:00","licence_basis":"ODC-By 1.0 (Open Data Commons Attribution) — Getty Vocabularies, Union List of Artist Names, vocab.getty.edu","reader_version":"rdoc-multi-2.2.0"},"precision":"NOT_APPLICABLE","predicate":"death_place","depends_on":null,"event_type":"DEATH","quantifier":"SINGLE","attribution":"J. Paul Getty Trust, Getty Vocabulary Program — Union List of Artist Names (ULAN)®","source_work":"getty:500000149","uncertainty":null,"assertion_id":296142,"source_family":"ULAN","subject_scope":"entity:29b71f8f-d0e7-44a3-aa2d-74d201f6744d"}],"claim_id":170435,"precision":"NOT_APPLICABLE","predicate":"death_place","admitted_at":"2026-09-30T09:12:05.965391+00:00","decision_id":237427},{"value":{"text":"1945","year":1945,"precision":"YEAR"},"support":[{"role":"SUBJECT","value":{"text":"1945","year":1945,"precision":"YEAR"},"locator":{"verbatim":"1945","field_path":"548[0]$a[1]","locator_id":451981},"snapshot":{"revision":"20080717110957.0","access_url":"https://d-nb.info/gnd/11927907X/about/marcxml","http_status":200,"snapshot_id":67329,"source_work":"gnd:11927907X","content_hash":"533b7c5c83fd298b507501659e6459054da4f81ad329f5aab10407ed9ce513e3","retrieved_at":"2026-09-30T13:53:29.018935+00:00","licence_basis":"CC0 1.0 (Deutsche Nationalbibliothek, Gemeinsame Normdatei, d-nb.info)","reader_version":"rdoc-multi-2.2.0"},"precision":"YEAR","predicate":"died","depends_on":null,"event_type":"DEATH","quantifier":"SINGLE","attribution":"Deutsche Nationalbibliothek, Gemeinsame Normdatei","source_work":"gnd:11927907X","uncertainty":null,"assertion_id":311846,"source_family":"DNB-GND","subject_scope":"entity:29b71f8f-d0e7-44a3-aa2d-74d201f6744d"},{"role":"SUBJECT","value":{"text":"1945","year":1945,"precision":"YEAR"},"locator":{"verbatim":"1945","field_path":"$.died.timespan","locator_id":428469},"snapshot":{"revision":"","access_url":"https://vocab.getty.edu/ulan/500000149.json","http_status":200,"snapshot_id":64020,"source_work":"getty:500000149","content_hash":"f3efe07c8d2db74e9d54f113ead1afce337b8608e0af92907f547c9b3d9ec3d8","retrieved_at":"2026-09-30T09:12:05.965391+00:00","licence_basis":"ODC-By 1.0 (Open Data Commons Attribution) — Getty Vocabularies, Union List of Artist Names, vocab.getty.edu","reader_version":"rdoc-multi-2.2.0"},"precision":"YEAR","predicate":"died","depends_on":null,"event_type":"DEATH","quantifier":"SINGLE","attribution":"J. Paul Getty Trust, Getty Vocabulary Program — Union List of Artist Names (ULAN)®","source_work":"getty:500000149","uncertainty":null,"assertion_id":296141,"source_family":"ULAN","subject_scope":"entity:29b71f8f-d0e7-44a3-aa2d-74d201f6744d"}],"claim_id":170434,"precision":"YEAR","predicate":"died","admitted_at":"2026-09-30T09:12:05.965391+00:00","decision_id":237426},{"value":{"text":"artists (visual artists)"},"support":[{"role":"OCCUPATION","value":{"text":"artists (visual artists)","authority_id":"http://vocab.getty.edu/aat/300025103"},"locator":{"verbatim":"artists (visual artists)","field_path":"$.classified_as[0]._label","locator_id":428471},"snapshot":{"revision":"","access_url":"https://vocab.getty.edu/ulan/500000149.json","http_status":200,"snapshot_id":64020,"source_work":"getty:500000149","content_hash":"f3efe07c8d2db74e9d54f113ead1afce337b8608e0af92907f547c9b3d9ec3d8","retrieved_at":"2026-09-30T09:12:05.965391+00:00","licence_basis":"ODC-By 1.0 (Open Data Commons Attribution) — Getty Vocabularies, Union List of Artist Names, vocab.getty.edu","reader_version":"rdoc-multi-2.2.0"},"precision":"NOT_APPLICABLE","predicate":"occupation","depends_on":null,"event_type":"ACTIVITY","quantifier":"ONE_OF_LISTED","attribution":"J. Paul Getty Trust, Getty Vocabulary Program — Union List of Artist Names (ULAN)®","source_work":"getty:500000149","uncertainty":null,"assertion_id":296143,"source_family":"ULAN","subject_scope":"entity:29b71f8f-d0e7-44a3-aa2d-74d201f6744d"}],"claim_id":170436,"precision":"NOT_APPLICABLE","predicate":"occupation","admitted_at":"2026-09-30T09:12:05.965391+00:00","decision_id":237428},{"value":{"text":"designers"},"support":[{"role":"OCCUPATION","value":{"text":"designers","authority_id":"http://vocab.getty.edu/aat/300025190"},"locator":{"verbatim":"designers","field_path":"$.classified_as[1]._label","locator_id":428472},"snapshot":{"revision":"","access_url":"https://vocab.getty.edu/ulan/500000149.json","http_status":200,"snapshot_id":64020,"source_work":"getty:500000149","content_hash":"f3efe07c8d2db74e9d54f113ead1afce337b8608e0af92907f547c9b3d9ec3d8","retrieved_at":"2026-09-30T09:12:05.965391+00:00","licence_basis":"ODC-By 1.0 (Open Data Commons Attribution) — Getty Vocabularies, Union List of Artist Names, vocab.getty.edu","reader_version":"rdoc-multi-2.2.0"},"precision":"NOT_APPLICABLE","predicate":"occupation","depends_on":null,"event_type":"ACTIVITY","quantifier":"ONE_OF_LISTED","attribution":"J. Paul Getty Trust, Getty Vocabulary Program — Union List of Artist Names (ULAN)®","source_work":"getty:500000149","uncertainty":null,"assertion_id":296144,"source_family":"ULAN","subject_scope":"entity:29b71f8f-d0e7-44a3-aa2d-74d201f6744d"}],"claim_id":170437,"precision":"NOT_APPLICABLE","predicate":"occupation","admitted_at":"2026-09-30T09:12:05.965391+00:00","decision_id":237429},{"value":{"text":"muralists (painters)"},"support":[{"role":"OCCUPATION","value":{"text":"muralists (painters)","authority_id":"http://vocab.getty.edu/aat/300025153"},"locator":{"verbatim":"muralists (painters)","field_path":"$.classified_as[2]._label","locator_id":428473},"snapshot":{"revision":"","access_url":"https://vocab.getty.edu/ulan/500000149.json","http_status":200,"snapshot_id":64020,"source_work":"getty:500000149","content_hash":"f3efe07c8d2db74e9d54f113ead1afce337b8608e0af92907f547c9b3d9ec3d8","retrieved_at":"2026-09-30T09:12:05.965391+00:00","licence_basis":"ODC-By 1.0 (Open Data Commons Attribution) — Getty Vocabularies, Union List of Artist Names, vocab.getty.edu","reader_version":"rdoc-multi-2.2.0"},"precision":"NOT_APPLICABLE","predicate":"occupation","depends_on":null,"event_type":"ACTIVITY","quantifier":"ONE_OF_LISTED","attribution":"J. Paul Getty Trust, Getty Vocabulary Program — Union List of Artist Names (ULAN)®","source_work":"getty:500000149","uncertainty":null,"assertion_id":296145,"source_family":"ULAN","subject_scope":"entity:29b71f8f-d0e7-44a3-aa2d-74d201f6744d"}],"claim_id":170438,"precision":"NOT_APPLICABLE","predicate":"occupation","admitted_at":"2026-09-30T09:12:05.965391+00:00","decision_id":237430},{"value":{"text":"watercolorists"},"support":[{"role":"OCCUPATION","value":{"text":"watercolorists","authority_id":"http://vocab.getty.edu/aat/300025157"},"locator":{"verbatim":"watercolorists","field_path":"$.classified_as[3]._label","locator_id":428474},"snapshot":{"revision":"","access_url":"https://vocab.getty.edu/ulan/500000149.json","http_status":200,"snapshot_id":64020,"source_work":"getty:500000149","content_hash":"f3efe07c8d2db74e9d54f113ead1afce337b8608e0af92907f547c9b3d9ec3d8","retrieved_at":"2026-09-30T09:12:05.965391+00:00","licence_basis":"ODC-By 1.0 (Open Data Commons Attribution) — Getty Vocabularies, Union List of Artist Names, vocab.getty.edu","reader_version":"rdoc-multi-2.2.0"},"precision":"NOT_APPLICABLE","predicate":"occupation","depends_on":null,"event_type":"ACTIVITY","quantifier":"ONE_OF_LISTED","attribution":"J. Paul Getty Trust, Getty Vocabulary Program — Union List of Artist Names (ULAN)®","source_work":"getty:500000149","uncertainty":null,"assertion_id":296146,"source_family":"ULAN","subject_scope":"entity:29b71f8f-d0e7-44a3-aa2d-74d201f6744d"}],"claim_id":170439,"precision":"NOT_APPLICABLE","predicate":"occupation","admitted_at":"2026-09-30T09:12:05.965391+00:00","decision_id":237431},{"value":{"text":"illustrators"},"support":[{"role":"OCCUPATION","value":{"text":"illustrators","authority_id":"http://vocab.getty.edu/aat/300025123"},"locator":{"verbatim":"illustrators","field_path":"$.classified_as[4]._label","locator_id":428475},"snapshot":{"revision":"","access_url":"https://vocab.getty.edu/ulan/500000149.json","http_status":200,"snapshot_id":64020,"source_work":"getty:500000149","content_hash":"f3efe07c8d2db74e9d54f113ead1afce337b8608e0af92907f547c9b3d9ec3d8","retrieved_at":"2026-09-30T09:12:05.965391+00:00","licence_basis":"ODC-By 1.0 (Open Data Commons Attribution) — Getty Vocabularies, Union List of Artist Names, vocab.getty.edu","reader_version":"rdoc-multi-2.2.0"},"precision":"NOT_APPLICABLE","predicate":"occupation","depends_on":null,"event_type":"ACTIVITY","quantifier":"ONE_OF_LISTED","attribution":"J. Paul Getty Trust, Getty Vocabulary Program — Union List of Artist Names (ULAN)®","source_work":"getty:500000149","uncertainty":null,"assertion_id":296147,"source_family":"ULAN","subject_scope":"entity:29b71f8f-d0e7-44a3-aa2d-74d201f6744d"}],"claim_id":170440,"precision":"NOT_APPLICABLE","predicate":"occupation","admitted_at":"2026-09-30T09:12:05.965391+00:00","decision_id":237432},{"value":{"text":"painters (artists)"},"support":[{"role":"OCCUPATION","value":{"text":"painters (artists)","authority_id":"http://vocab.getty.edu/aat/300025136"},"locator":{"verbatim":"painters (artists)","field_path":"$.classified_as[5]._label","locator_id":428476},"snapshot":{"revision":"","access_url":"https://vocab.getty.edu/ulan/500000149.json","http_status":200,"snapshot_id":64020,"source_work":"getty:500000149","content_hash":"f3efe07c8d2db74e9d54f113ead1afce337b8608e0af92907f547c9b3d9ec3d8","retrieved_at":"2026-09-30T09:12:05.965391+00:00","licence_basis":"ODC-By 1.0 (Open Data Commons Attribution) — Getty Vocabularies, Union List of Artist Names, vocab.getty.edu","reader_version":"rdoc-multi-2.2.0"},"precision":"NOT_APPLICABLE","predicate":"occupation","depends_on":null,"event_type":"ACTIVITY","quantifier":"ONE_OF_LISTED","attribution":"J. Paul Getty Trust, Getty Vocabulary Program — Union List of Artist Names (ULAN)®","source_work":"getty:500000149","uncertainty":null,"assertion_id":296148,"source_family":"ULAN","subject_scope":"entity:29b71f8f-d0e7-44a3-aa2d-74d201f6744d"}],"claim_id":170441,"precision":"NOT_APPLICABLE","predicate":"occupation","admitted_at":"2026-09-30T09:12:05.965391+00:00","decision_id":237433},{"value":{"text":"Künstler"},"support":[{"role":"OCCUPATION","value":{"text":"Künstler","authority_id":"https://d-nb.info/gnd/4033423-5"},"locator":{"verbatim":"Künstler","field_path":"550[0]$a","locator_id":451982},"snapshot":{"revision":"20080717110957.0","access_url":"https://d-nb.info/gnd/11927907X/about/marcxml","http_status":200,"snapshot_id":67329,"source_work":"gnd:11927907X","content_hash":"533b7c5c83fd298b507501659e6459054da4f81ad329f5aab10407ed9ce513e3","retrieved_at":"2026-09-30T13:53:29.018935+00:00","licence_basis":"CC0 1.0 (Deutsche Nationalbibliothek, Gemeinsame Normdatei, d-nb.info)","reader_version":"rdoc-multi-2.2.0"},"precision":"NOT_APPLICABLE","predicate":"occupation","depends_on":null,"event_type":"ACTIVITY","quantifier":"ONE_OF_LISTED","attribution":"Deutsche Nationalbibliothek, Gemeinsame Normdatei","source_work":"gnd:11927907X","uncertainty":null,"assertion_id":311847,"source_family":"DNB-GND","subject_scope":"entity:29b71f8f-d0e7-44a3-aa2d-74d201f6744d"}],"claim_id":179876,"precision":"NOT_APPLICABLE","predicate":"occupation","admitted_at":"2026-09-30T13:53:29.018935+00:00","decision_id":250153}],"version":1,"entity_id":"29b71f8f-d0e7-44a3-aa2d-74d201f6744d","revision_id":26032,"verified_at":"2026-10-07T23:49:56.685317+00:00","activated_at":"2026-10-07T23:34:32.464893+00:00","candidate_id":180562,"content_hash":"2a728d9dc96d98bc3a3f327fa5ea6d98","unresolved_claim_ids":[]}